The Plane Crash


I read up on the crash and the facts state the plane collided with the tops of trees on a hillside. In the movie it looked like it was a lightning strike that took down the plane. Why would they change this fact in the movie?

reply

I think the filmmakers didn't want to focus on the graphic nature of the crash as that wasn't what the film was about (unlike "Alive" for eg.) The flash of light just represented the quick and sudden demise of the flight -- it was all over in a heartbeat. I don't believe they meant to mislead. They just didn't want to make that the focus of the movie or the most memorable scene. All IMHO of course.

reply

I see what you are saying, but I think the filmakers should have just had the players going on the plane, do a fade-out and then cut straight to the wreckage of the plane with a news broadcast explaining the apparent cause of the crash - which was the trees. Seeing a single lightning strike take down the plane was amateurish as lightning strikes dont take down airlines. They are capable of sustaining multiple lightning strikes.

reply

The crash involved a DC 9 jet owned by the now-defunct Southern Airways on a charter flight from Kinston NC. While attempting an instrument approach to Runway 12 at HTS, Huntington WV airport, in rain and fog, the pilots impacted a hill which is about 3/4 of a mile west of the runway threshold. The NTSB called the accident "CFIT" or Controlled Flight Into Terrain.

Flight 932 was normal in all respects up to that point. The flight had received the latest weather report from Huntington Tower and was cleared to initiate an instrument approach to RW 12, which would allow a safe descent to visual conditions, lined up with the centerline. The procedure was called a "non-precision approach": that is...an approach without an electronic glide path to the runway. Experienced commercial pilots are well trained on this kind of procedure and while they prefer an ILS approach with glide path, the non-precision approach is doable, provided the aircraft does not go below "minimums" or the MDA until the runway is in sight and the plane is in position for a normal landing. Minimums on that approach to Huntington was 1240 feet msl. For some reason, the pilot elected to go 400 feet lower, and failed to clear the hill off the approach end of the runway.

If he hadn't had the runway in sight, then he should have applied max power, pitched up, and climbed back up to an assigned altitude on a "go-around" or "missed approach" procedure for that runway. From a safe altitude high above the terrain, the pilot's would have then decided to either hold for better weather conditions, initiate another approach or fly to their alternate airport.

This crash, like all CFIT events with commercial aircraft, was very sad and unnecessary .

It was the worse loss of a sports team in a plane crash in history.

Modern jets are now equipped with GPS, and can conduct what is called an RNAV approach, which has an electronic glide path for the pilot to follow, besides the usual ILS. Most approaches still have "minimums" with same proviso...visual contact with the runway or go-around. HTS airport now has ILS and RNAV approaches to both runways as well as approach control radar and the airport has maintained an excellent safety record since the 1970 crash.

CmdrCody



CmdrCody.

reply

Lightning means they don't have to show the crew screwing up, no liability that way.

reply

There was no conspiracy as the investigation said it was from trees so obviously the families knew it wasn't caused by lightning. What's the filmakers intentions then? Unless it was first reported that it was caused by lightning and later rectified in the investigation?

reply

Imo you're making a false assumption from the start: indeed the last time we see the interior of the aircraft there is a lightning flash (and there were a few more before iirc), but that is just to show that this flight was on approach in a thunderstorm, or in bad weather anyway.

It's not depicted and is not meant as a lighting struck that caused the aircraft to fall.

reply

Good point. You may well be right. If thats the case, I retract everything I said.

reply

What I didn't understand (rather minor point though) was that just before the plane crashes the pilot announces that they're landing but apparently the townspeople and other football players who didn't get on the plane are able to drive up to the crash scene with what seems minutes. Goof in editing perhaps?

----------
..I'm fine with both nudity and violence

reply

It is not necessarily inaccurate, as a whole. Note that the movie implies that the fire trucks got there first. Not hard to follow on the heels of a fire truck.

First, Huntington is a small city in which you can get from one point to another quickly. The crash was devastating and would have likely been heard even before the word got out.

Second, the airport, and more specifically, the crash site are very close to town, and close to a 2-lane highway that allows direct path access to the crash site.

This is corroborated in the FAA final accident report write up, and visible in satellite imagery.

reply

[deleted]

Yes...that is right. No thunderstorm was near Huntington during the approach of the Southern Airways jet.

Instead, there was low ceilings and visibility during the approach, which obscured both the airport and the ridge west of the field which the aircraft impacted. As I mentioned, the pilot flying the aircraft elected to go below minimums for the instrument approach without adequate visual reference to the runway.

He crashed a perfectly good airplane full of people into the ridge...a tragic mistake which cost everyone on board their life.

CmdrCody

reply

Smh it's so sad that they were literally RIGHT THERE almost landing and the plane went down. Just horrible. Did anyone sue? It was the 70s so people weren't as sue happy like today. If this happened today, there would be lawsuits up the ass.

It's crazy that the pilot ignored protocol and got everyone killed so close to landing. Makes you wonder what the pilot was even thinking to be lower than he should have been. I mean, his life is also on the line. You would think he would be more careful. Maybe he just felt safe and ignored any worry since they were about to land. He figured they were already home so nothing bad could happen at that point.


reply

My husband is from Huntington. He had been a student at Marshall, too, but left school to go to work full time. He, his wife at the time and some friends were downtown at Monty's Pizza on 6th Avenue. The waitress came out from the kitchen and broke the news. No one in the restaurant had heard the crash or been in a position to see it. Monty came out a few minutes later and put a B&W TV on the counter so they could watch the coverage on the local news. Everyone was stunned, of course.

When they got outside about a half-hour later, they could smell the jet fuel, and worse. They were all in their early 20s and curious, as you might expect, to go get a close up view of the crash. The police had already cordoned off I-75, however, which was the route to the airport. The crash happened in a remote area; it was very dark, and very rainy. It was not possible -- as shown in the movie -- to drive up to the scene, hop out of the car and run over to gawk at the burning plane.

The crash devastated Huntington and the surrounding area. It was many years before things began to feel normal again. People who didn't know anyone on the plane knew someone who did, or who was related to one or more of the victims. Tom didn't know any of those who were killed, but his best friend did. He went to the Xavier game and he and hundreds of other people took to the field after the game, as shown in the movie. No one wanted to go home; they felt like savoring the victory with families and friends. Many people recall this night as having been the first time they had smiled in 11 months.

reply

My husband is from Huntington. He had been a student at Marshall, too, but left school to go to work full time. He, his wife at the time and some friends were downtown at Monty's Pizza on 6th Avenue. The waitress came out from the kitchen and broke the news. No one in the restaurant had heard the crash or been in a position to see it. Monty came out a few minutes later and put a B&W TV on the counter so they could watch the coverage on the local news. Everyone was stunned, of course.

When they got outside about a half-hour later, they could smell the jet fuel, and worse. They were all in their early 20s and curious, as you might expect, to go get a close up view of the crash. The police had already cordoned off I-75, however, which was the route to the airport. The crash happened in a remote area; it was very dark, and very rainy. It was not possible -- as shown in the movie -- to drive up to the scene, hop out of the car and run over to gawk at the burning plane.

The crash devastated Huntington and the surrounding area. It was many years before things began to feel normal again. People who didn't know anyone on the plane knew someone who did, or who was related to one or more of the victims. Tom didn't know any of those who were killed, but his best friend did. He went to the Xavier game and he and hundreds of other people took to the field after the game, as shown in the movie. No one wanted to go home; they felt like savoring the victory with families and friends. Many people recall this night as having been the first time they had smiled in 11 months.
That was wonderful perspective. Thanks for it.

reply

I am going to agree with others here.

I think that the flash that many assumed was lighting was, in fact, the impact of the plane slamming into the hill and the huge fireball that was likely created.

Destroying an Empire to win a war is no victory, and ending a battle to save an Empire is no defeat.

reply

its just a fade to a white light. That's you claiming lightning. The movie never says Lightning was the cause. That's your take on it which is mistaken

reply