Susie Carter


How did people find Susie Carter's character? I was annoyed at her for some of the time - she kept pushing the blame to Ian for letting go of Martha, when she herself didn't see the situation. I was glad when he finally told her that he didn't create that situation. It just happened. She relented after that.
At the same time, I was worried about her - she just took the child, Eve, and thought she could just replace Martha with this child. I thought she was just going to lose her mind. (I don't know, I wasn't in that situation). What a trade off, since the child's parents were missing. But Eve and Martha would have been quite different, even though they were cute, sweet-looking 6 year girls, who look almost similar; they would have different likes, characteristics, temperaments etc.

reply

Not to mention one was Thai!
Lol
I was worried for her, slightly annoyed, but more worried. Can't imagine how she must have felt at the time!

Dean Learner: She was like a candle in the wind... unreliable.

reply

[deleted]

She might have been French! I'm not too sure. What do you mean, "Carry on?"

reply

She wasn't Thai, her mother was obviously French speaking.

The sun shone, having no alternative, on the nothing new. Samuel Beckett

reply

I fell asleep - did they find Martha?

reply

No

reply

Are these characters fictionous? If they are real, I'd like to find an update on her family! How have they coped.

Did they ever find Martha's body for burial (post production). Etc. I'm sure they have found her body eventually right? Not to sound indelicate but the body must have washed ashore somewhere right?

I would hate always wondering if Martha has amnesia somewhere alive with another family or did she die? Personally I would prefer to believe the first but not knowing would be so hard!

reply

50,000 people have never been found. Most likely Martha is one of them.

reply

Her character made me so angry. So angry! Angry to the point where I didn't feel any sympathy for her at all after a while, and was waiting for her husband to finally snap and tell her a few things she needed to hear. I almost cheered when that happened. While some of the things he said to her weren't exactly accurate, or even fair, they still weren't nearly as bad as what she said to him, and she definitely had it coming. She wasn't the only one who lost that child, and she didn't have to deal with the guilt of having 'let go' on top of that. Horrible woman! She and her husband should have been holding each other up, and instead she spent most of the movie tearing him down. She even went a little crazy when another little girl came along, and immediately tried to replace Martha. Well, 'replace' doesn't really fit, but that's the closest word I could come up with. I know different people have different ways of grieving. Some isolate themselves, some cry, some seem to get over it quickly, but I just couldn't stand Susie in the movie. I'm sorry, but I truly hated her.

And her husband forgave her at the end of it. She didn't deserve forgiveness, in my opinion. He went through Hell to find her and to find out what happened to Martha, and he just sat there and took it when she was being awful to him. Some people might argue that her reaction was 'very human', as a friend of mine said when we watched this, but that's neither here nor there. Humans are capable of horrible behavior, and whatever grief this woman was going through, her grief was all she thought about when there was still her grieving husband to consider, and to me this makes her horrible. That man was a saint to stay with her!

reply

Do you have children? Are you a Mother? I m 100% sure you re not. You re probably young, not seen or experienced much. When you have, or when you become a Mother, I think you will be very ashamed and embarrassed by your defiant judgement of Susie Carter. I am sure of that.

reply

Yes, I just saw this movie and her blaming her husband was brutal to watch. I know she couldn't help it, but damn. She was starting to really annoy me.

reply