MovieChat Forums > Death Note: Desu nôto (2006) Discussion > Is Death Note The Greatest Anime Ever?

Is Death Note The Greatest Anime Ever?


i'm doing a pole.write your top 5 anime and Death Note's position(if it's not in it).
for me:
1#Death Note
2#Elfen Lied
3#Neon Genesis Evangelion
4#Code Geass
5#Trigun



I know it's kinda wrong,since we are in a Death Note board,but i wanna see what else Death Note fans like...


reply

[deleted]

I loved Samurai Champloo a bit more.
And now I watch Naruto - but not enjoy so much.

reply

[deleted]

1. Evangelion
2. Cowboy Bebop
3. Monster
4. Berserk
5. Baccano!

reply

1 Gungrave (sweet dear lord why is this not on a list yet?)
2 Outlaw Star
3 Cowboy Bebop
4 Paranoia Agent and Death Note tied
5 Trigun and FLCL tied

If Death Note would have ended it in 26 episodes it would be tied with Cowboy Bebop but the show completely jumped the shark after L died.

reply

My top 5, if movies count:

1 Neon Genesis Evangelion (series & movies)
2 Mysterious Cities of Gold (sheer nostalgy)
3 Death Note, tied with Kenshin OVA
4 Akira
5 Laputa Castle in the Sky

reply

Agree with you savvyspence. They shouldn't have continued the manga, If anything they should have just made the L arc a lil bit longer and end it there instead of dragging it on until it became a shadow of its former self

reply

THANKS

reply

Yes, it is.

reply

It's not at all the greatest. But, it's exceptionally good for the first 26 episodes or so.

What should one care to say?

reply

That's right. With L's death, the anime goes down.

reply

even with 37 episodes ,death note is still the best.I know it's not that good than the first arc,but give it a break ,and it was going insanely good for the most part and a few not-so-good episodes or underdeveloped characters aren't enough to say it sucks.I mean just look other anime with 200 and more episodes that are clearly fillers.

reply

Nobody said it sucked. I pointed out that it was exceptionally good for 26 episodes or so. It stands out from other animes in these episodes, but in its entirety it's not at all the greatest. That's all I said, anyway.

What should one care to say?

reply

waiting for replys,here's some other i've seen and i think there great.

Cowboy Bebop
Higurashi
Chobits
The Melancholy Of Haruhi Suzumiya

I'm watching Monster now,it's ok but too long for my taste(74 episodes).I'm in 35.

reply

a small update on a show i watched and recommend:

Fruits Basket
Also,i have only watched 3 anime movies(except the end of eva)that are really interesting to watch,each for it's own reasons:

Akira
Ghost in the Shell
Spirited Away (especially that was amazing)

reply

They had to do the 37 episodes including the final arc with Near and Mello, because that's the story the original comic told. If they just ended it at 26 episodes and L's death, then I bet a lot of people would be complaining that it "bastardized" the original comic...

reply

That's true but it doesn't matter. It's still a poor part of the anime, regardless of the manga. Because yeah, you SHOULD judge the two as separate entities....

reply

i agree, you can't have it both ways
if you want to tell the ENTIRE story, then you also have to accept that parts certain arcs are good and others are a bit contrived

What should one care to say?

reply

THANK YOU SO MUCH, YOU FÚCKING *beep*

"Geez, she fell funny!" - Frank Costello (The Departed)
Y SO SIRIUS?

reply

I felt the same exact way, i just kept waiting for L to somehow come back, but it never happened...bummer.

reply

It's good, not great. Is losing me, and is way too stretched out and too many new things throw into the mix as the show went along.

Thanks,
www.segacduniverse.com

- Mike

reply

Overall:
1#Dragon Ball Z
2#Death Note
3#Naruto
4#Guyver (original version)
5#Trigun


Dubbed into Arabic that I saw as a child:
1#Grendizer
2#Plawres Sanshiro
3#Combattler V
4#Captain Tsubasa
5#Igano Kabamaru

reply

1. Evangelion
2. Death Note
3. Fullmetal Alchemist
4. Mobile Suit Gundam
5. Ghost in the Shell

reply

Here you go.

1# Cowboy Bebop
2# Elfen Lied
3# Deathnote
4# Serial Experiments Lain
5# Boogiepop Phantom

reply

[deleted]

I can't choose an order... but:

Cowboy Bebop
Samurai Champloo
Death Note
Fullmetal Alchemist
Bleach
Hellsing
Wolf's Rain
Gantz

reply

two really awesome shows i watched over the past month.
Azumanga Daioh
Black Lagoon

Also i watched the movie "perfect blue" which was nice.

[edit]i would also like to make a change in my top 5.After some thought... i'm putting Trigun at #4 and Code Geass at #5.

reply

Death Note and Monster get my vote for top 2



"When I was a kid I inhaled frequently. That was the point."- Barack Obama

reply