Darkness everywhere


This is a solid piece of work, but it suffers from a surfeit of extremely dark scenes that were probably discernible on the big screen. But when you watch the DVD on small-screen TV, you have literally no idea what is going on in these scenes. The screen is just an opaque mass.

The critical five-minute ending in this movie is bathed almost entirely in black, and considerable drama is lost on the viewer. I knew what was happening, and I did see a couple of flashes of faces, but that's about it. This is a big problem with digital cameras -- they just don't capture darkness very well when transferred to much smaller screens.

Too bad about this technical stuff, because overall I think Der Freie Wille/Free Will is a good study of the deviant human mind -- not just of the rapist, but of the obsessed woman who loves him. The biggest problem for me was balance: we are given effective insights into why the woman behaves the way she does, but we know next to nothing about the man, except that he's a 'monster'. Not good enough.

reply

You need to calibrate your tv.

reply

I agree! I'm watching it right now and at times it's just too dark to basically see anything!
When watching on TV, that quality is somewhat better though (I first watched it on the computer).

The world can't end today. It's already tomorrow in Australia.

reply

But that's the genius of it, that he is just "a monster." He wasn't made into one, he just is. We're not privvied to tales of horrid experiences from when he was a child, or any kind of justification. We're left to either imagine that _something_ drove him to be this way, or rather to infer that it's by nature, a mental disorder, a demon inside him as he says. I reckon it's the latter because he says as much.

He could not be rehabilitated. He tried to move on, to resist his urges. He even had a woman-- a fellow tortured soul-- present herself to him for a normal relationship, but he couldn't do it.

I know it's cold to say this, but such tortured souls, really, they are weapons of mass destruction. He made the only honorable choice: suicide.

reply

considerable drama was lost because of the darkness? Were we watching the same movie? Ever thought it might be a conscious choice? :)

"Doublethink. To deliberately believe in lies, while knowing they're false." Henry Barthes

reply