This game is bogus!


So me and my roomate decided to break this game out last night since we haven't played in awhile. Just a little background information; neither of my roomates has beaten me since we first got the game (based mainly on the fact that the PS2 is in my room and I practice more often).

Anyways, we were playing "Hey You" on HARD. This is one of the easiest songs of the game by far so I was a little nervous that if I was going to lose, this would probably be the song to do it. When the song was done and the smoke had cleared, my roomate beat me by 700 or so points. But here's the part that makes me think this game is bogus. I got 100% while my roomate got 99%. My note streak was like 350 while her's was 230 something. How is it possible that she beat me?! Well, she had 4 star power opportunities while I only got 3! How did that happen? Neither one of us was sitting on them, we were using them right when they became available.

I didn't hear the end of it for the whole night and I'm sure all day today. Does anyone have any idea why this game sucks so hard? How did I lose with 100%???? Any input would be appreciated.

Nuke the whales . . . gotta nuke somethin'!

reply

The game 'sucks so hard' because you lost to your roommate? LOL, it sounds like YOU are the one who is bogus, my friend.

The only reason for your roommate getting a higher score than you, would be that she activated her star power in sections with more notes. More notes = more multiplied points.

reply

In hard mode, the song Hey You has 544 notes (according to scorehero.com).

Now, if you got 100% notes hit, yet your longest streak was 350, that means you must have overstrummed several times while still hitting every note. Every time you overstrum, your multiplier resets to 1x.

The only thing that the fact your longest streak was better than your friend's longest streak means you had one demonstrable instance in which you had a longer multiplier than she did (for example, she could have had two streaks of 230 notes each, while you had one 350-note streak, then no streaks over 40 thereafter; this would give her a 4x multiplier thorughout nearly the whole song, whereas you would only have a 4x multiplier for half the song, and it constantly reset to 1x - though this example would give her more than enough points to beat you by well over 700 points).

I'm willing to bet that if you had looked at the number of streaks broken by each of you, you would have had more. Also, this being Guitar Hero 1, the only co-op mode is face-off, which does not guarantee a perfectly symmetrical scoring method (that is, your friend could have had far more notes when she activated star power, as mentioned above, or simply more notes in general, which allows here the possibility for a greater score, even if you two perform perfectly evenly). Added to the fact that she had two star power usages to your one (i assume if you had three phrases, and used star power as soon as it became available, you would have had one unused portion throughout the rest of the song), it is not unsound logic at all to assume she beat you, especially by as little as 700 points (which, at a 4x multiplier, can be achieved by getting as little as four notes or two chords). Mathematically, every aspect of the scorekeeping in-game works out perfectly.

Because real men eat pie.

reply

Also, if you didn't hold all of your sustained notes until the very end, you could have missed out on some points. You could hit every note and get 100% with a 544 note streak and have the same star power and still get two different scores if you don't sustain every note till the end.

"Why in the name of Merlin's saggy left..."

reply

Assuming the scoring system is the same in GH II, I've had something similar happen as far as chords go. On pro-face off, you have the same exact set of notes for each player, and if both players don't miss a single note for a while, it takes a while for the meeter in the middle to stop being neutral (white in color, as opposed to blue for player one or red for player two). I have witnessed it go blue when I was player two and I was hitting the same notes as my roommate because I stopped holding the fret button earlier than my opponent on a chord. What's mroe, I've beaten my roommate by getting a lower percentage than her but getting a higher score. Points determine the winner.

reply

The game isn't bogus, it's the fact your room mate scored more points than you. The game counts the final score, NOT the percentage.

---
"I couldn't commit suicide if my life depended on it" - George Carlin

reply