overrated/underrate d


ok, so this is ONLY for their comedy central special, nothing else. who would you say has the most overrated/underrated special.

Overrated=dane cook
underrated=tom cotter, or brian regan.

reply

Overrated= Lisa Lampanelli
Underrated=Ben Bailey, Pablo Fransisco

No Sugar Tonight In My Coffee

reply

[deleted]

Brian Regan is amazing! Next to zero swear words...I could sit through his set with my grandmother. Not to mention the entire half-hour was seamless because the guy is so good with segues.

Dane Cook is his polar opposite - really jarring subject changes and completely pointless f-bombs. Without his delivery, he's got nothing. He doesn't even really tell jokes...just stories.

reply

Overrated:Dane Cook
Underrated: the greatest comedian of all time, Mitch hedberg

"It's a dog eat dog,
eat cat too,
fish eat frog,
I eat you."
-Bon Scott

reply

Overrated: Ron White

Underrated: Jim Gaffigan

reply

[deleted]

I was shocked to that no one counted Larry the Cable Guy as the most overrated, but then I remembered you asked us to list comedians. Bob Zany could use a little more respect.

reply

Overrated: Dane Cook (his best stuff was not on his special)

Underrated: Mike Birbiglia, Brian Regan (my favorite of all-time), Tom Cotter, Jim Gaffigan








If you love Jesus Christ and are 100% proud of it copy this and make your signature

reply

Overrated: New Holness aka Carlos Mencia this guys sucks...


Underrated:Mitch Hedberg RIP you will be missed..

"All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy."

reply

Over: Dane Cook

Under: Kyle Dunnigan and Adam Ferrara

reply

Overrated: Dane Cook (sucks)
Underrated: Lewis Black

I like Ron White, and think that he has more talent than the other 3 Blue Collar guys (especially Bill Engvall).

reply

Adam Ferrara was HILARIOUS!

reply

Overrated: Dat Phan
Underrated (I have a lot): Tom Papa, Adam Ferrera, Greg Proops, Elvira Kurt, Jack Coen

I actually loved Dane Cook's CCP special. I have had the interest to watch or hear him elsewhere, but he makes me laugh every time I see his special. I'd say overall he's overrated.

reply

Getting away from your original post, I just want to go out on a limb and say that Demetri Martin sucks.
And after re-listening to some of the stuff Dane Cook has put out (aka everything after "Harmful If Swallowed") I don't mind him too much anymore. His bit about "15 Cents" was hilarious.

Overrated: Demetri Martin (blows hard), Dane Cook (still, although he is funny)
Underrated: Jim Gaffigan (hopefully his new cd is about more than food though), Daniel Tosh




Walter Sobchak: OVER THE LINE!
Smokey: Huh?

http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=22921473?c=1

reply

Overrated : Lisa Lampanelli

Underrated : Mitch Fatel

reply

Overrated - Larry the Cable Guy

Underrated - Dov Davidoff

reply

Overrated-Dane Cook, Lisa Lampanelli, Carlos Mencia
Underrated-Scott Kennedy, Sabrina the blonde lesbian, Jim Gaffigan

reply

over:Larry the cable guy, pete holmes, gabrieal inglasias(SP), jeff dunham

under: Steve Byrne, daniel tosh

reply


Totally agree with you about Larry The Cable Guy and Dov Davidoff.

Another Overrated: Jeff Dunham

Also some more underrated: Mitch Hedberg, Daniel Tosh, Maria Bamford and Donald Glover.

__________________________________
You know what I expected? Applause.

reply