One problem I had with this film


All right, this movie (which I generally liked)has one minor problem that is kinda bugging me. Ok, Nicole Ari Parker is a beautiful woman and the character she played can certainly make any man fall head over heels. Still, as beautiful as she is, I don't see how Roscoe Jenkins can lust after any woman when he is already engaged to someone as beautiful as Joy Bryant. I mean, if I had a girl like her I wouldn't ever need to even look at another woman. In fact, the whole script treats her kind of unfairly. At first, the movie wants us to like her, even over Parker's cahracter. When an excuse is needed for Roscoe to leave her, only then does she becoming a domineering pain. Even as such, I don't think she was as bad as the movie tried to make her out to be. What is so bad about wanting to keep her fiance in shape and, well, being jealous that he is lusting after a childhood sweetheart (which she had every right to be jealous about). The ending, when Lawrence leaves her to return home, is almost painful to watch. To see a guy leave behind a girl like Joy Bryant seems like such a waste. Just my two cents for what was otherwise an enjoyable movie.

reply

This is the same problem I had. I thought the movie was good and if it didnt use any curses it would be a good family movie.

But the end was forced. Bianca would not have the attitude towards his family if RJ didn't give her that impression of them. The blow up was out of nowhere and I didnt see the point. And wanting a woman after she is with your cousin is a lil desperate and not real IMO.

reply

The problem with Bianca is that she was too controlling from the beginning. For instance, his brother and cousin picked on him about the ribs because he really wants them and basically..."the boss" (as Roscoe's son described her)scolded him and told him that couldn't have any. It was also alluded to that she didn't have a great relationship with Roscoe's son, which should definitely send up red flags. And most of all, Roscoe didn't love Bianca, not really. She was a trophy wife and a pseudo-celebrity who was just out for money.

Oh, and the part about her doing anything to win plays into the whole R.J. Stevens to Roscoe Jenkins transition. I loved the part at the end when he Kicked Bianca to the curb because it showed growth; he was no longer ultra-competitive, he was making amends with his family and he was becoming the father to his son that he felt he never had. While Bianca was definitely hot...no doubt; Lucinda was the better woman for Roscoe.

reply

Here the truth. Bianca was dark-skinned compare to Nicole character. So the fair-skinned woman was going to be favored. Remember the movie Coming To America with Eddie Murphy? He was to marry a beautiful, dark-skinned woman in the beginning but they had her acting like a dog? So Eddie Murphy character went all the way to America and found his "true love" who happened to be fair-skinned. Noticed they made her sister(she was dark-skinned) a slut! There many instances in movies where this goes on in black films but its so underlined and hardly noticeable!

December 2007, Alvin and The Chipmunks just became relevant...again!

reply

I hate to admit it princeofnewyork, but you are right. This is something I have always noticed and as hard as it may be to imagine this going on in films to this day, I notice this in both "black" and "white" films, if those terms should even be applied. Honestly, I do not see why so many guys (black, white, and otherwise) think this way towards African-American women. It is even surprising to me because I am a white (Italian) American and have always been passionate about interracial dating. While I have dated many different kinds of women and will continue to date many different kinds until I find that right one, for some reason I have always "clicked" the most with African-American women. Who knows who I will end up with as my ultimate soulmate, but when I envision my ideal, it is always an African-American woman. I tell you guys (be they black, white, or whatever) that discriminate when it comes to dating have no idea the wonderful women that they are missing out on.

reply

I hate to admit it princeofnewyork, but you are right. This is something I have always noticed and as hard as it may be to imagine this going on in films to this day, I notice this in both "black" and "white" films, if those terms should even be applied. Honestly, I do not see why so many guys (black, white, and otherwise) think this way towards African-American women. It is even surprising to me because I am a white (Italian) American and have always been passionate about interracial dating. While I have dated many different kinds of women and will continue to date many different kinds until I find that right one, for some reason I have always "clicked" the most with African-American women. Who knows who I will end up with as my ultimate soulmate, but when I envision my ideal, it is always an African-American woman. I tell you guys (be they black, white, or whatever) that discriminate when it comes to dating have no idea the wonderful women that they are missing out on.

Thank you, rndicenso and thank you for sharing your story!

December 2007, Alvin and The Chipmunks just became relevant...again!

reply

princeofnewyork you hit the nail on the head! That light skinned is better mentality has been going on for years in the black community. As a medium skin tone person I see it all the time.

he picked the light skinned woman. It would have been better if he was with Nicole and left her for Joy, that would have been the shocker.

I appreciate the nice things that you said about African American women. It's been an interesting journey thus far.

reply

[deleted]

That makes no difference.

If Nicole was cast as the b*tch, and Joy as the childhood crush, the movie would played the same.

reply

Bianca represented the bougiouse mentality that blacks who consider themselves "down-to-earth" and "real", hate so much. The fact that she was disgusted by the sugar content of the Kool Aide and disapproved of Roscoe eating ribs was an indicator that she was on a different level than Roscoe's family. They played that up as an "us against them" theme in the whole film. When Roscoe jettisons her from the car at the end, it's seen as him coming to his senses and she's basically dubbed as the villain that's been keeping him from being a "real, down-to-earth" black man and keeping him away from his family. I didn't like how she was portrayed either. A better ending should have been Bianca truly bonding with Roscoe's family and accepting his son. Her character was so broad and cartoonish like a villain in those awful Tyler Perry movies.

reply

princeofnewyork, even in the scene, on Coming to America, when he was at the club and they showed clips of all different types of women, I think all the horrible ones were dark-skinned.

But I must say, growing up, it's unfortunate for me to say it, but I found dark-skinned girls to be meaner than light-skinned girls. And I know people will get upset at it, but I wish they would sit and listen before opening their mouths, listen to what I'm saying, I know you want to defend yourself or others, but I think we should use our TWO ears more than our ONE mouth.

But not all dark-skinned girls were mean, the girl in this movie and Vanessa Bell Calloway in CTA were more brown-skinned, some girls I grew up with that were very dark-skinned, seem to be meaner, especially those who had weight.

But it may be more with how society/their environment treats them versus how its treats light-skinned girls.

We (Males) are presented with light-skinned women everywhere, TV, Magazine Ads, Movies, etc. and they are shown to be better and much more desired, and suppose to be more attractive, but I've took the time to see dark-skinned women, and their beauty.

I have seen a lot of Beautiful Dark-skinned women, just being dark makes you beautiful (to me), but I think it's important that you take care of yourself, you know, being healthy, I wouldn't want an out of shape/or overweight woman whether black, white, or any race.

reply

But not all dark-skinned girls were mean, the girl in this movie and Vanessa Bell Calloway in CTA were more brown-skinned, some girls I grew up with that were very dark-skinned, seem to be meaner, especially those who had weight.


That has everything to do with self-image. Being very dark skinned and being overweight will not get you on the cover of magazines. Some women that see themselves as unattractive/undesirable tend to hate themselves and have a terrible self-image, and express that anger by being mean to others (men too).

And of course, the flip side of this is when people that know they are seen as highly attractive or desirable or more important than others tend to be dicks.

But back to "light vs dark", how many natural blondes dye their hair dark vs the reverse? The epitome of beauty in America is a young, blonde with straight hair, skinny, Aryan woman. The further away you get from that the less attractive a woman is thought to be. I even recall someone calling Halle Berry "a black woman in a white woman's body" because black women are usually thought of as being overweight. If you pay enough attention to movies and TV shows, the majority of dark skinned black women shown are over 30 and/or overweight. And the young attractive ones that are in shape are suspected of being mixed, because a black woman can't be attractive is she isn't mixed with something by America's standards.

"Action is how men express romance on film." -- Kurt Wimmer

reply

@C.S. Wood


That has everything to do with self-image. Being very dark skinned and being overweight will not get you on the cover of magazines.



Black-owned magazines have bigger women on them half the time. And the bottom line is, black women are treated as less attractive by the media no matter what size they are. Also, being dark-skinned and overweight does not automatically mean "unattractive",that's just a stereotype----believe me, I've seen plenty of attractive dark-skinned and overweight (by society's standards) women. Being blue-eyed and blonde alone does not make you attractive,either, and that is only thought to be the epitome of beauty only because he media keep shoving it down people's faces since even before movies and TV were invented.

If you pay enough attention to movies and TV shows, the majority of dark skinned black women shown are over 30 and/or overweight.

That isn't as true as it used to be---there are far more black women and women of color shown more on regular TV, partially due to showrunner Shonda Rimes and her hit shows full of diverse casts. Also, what does "over 30" have to do with anything? You make it sound like being over 30 is over the hill or some mess like that. I also think that the bigger black sisters are cast so that they won't take away the attention from the white women on some shows. That being said, I think comedian/former talk show host/actress Sheri Shepard, Yvette Nicole Brown (from the cult TV fave COMMUNITY) and Octavia Spencer (THE HELP,FRUITVALE STATION) are all beautiful dark-skinned lagre women.

reply

Black-owned magazines have bigger women on them half the time. And the bottom line is, black women are treated as less attractive by the media no matter what size they are. Also, being dark-skinned and overweight does not automatically mean "unattractive",that's just a stereotype----believe me, I've seen plenty of attractive dark-skinned and overweight (by society's standards) women. Being blue-eyed and blonde alone does not make you attractive,either, and that is only thought to be the epitome of beauty only because he media keep shoving it down people's faces since even before movies and TV were invented.


Well sure black magazines are going to have black women on them, the black magazines aren't the ones that need convincing. And although overweight doesn't automatically translate into unattractive, it is believed to be for a lot of these people. If Kate Upton gained 50 pounds the magazines would probably think twice about putting her on the cover.

I think we can safely say the the media's definition of beauty isn't as exclusive to white skin, blonde hair, blue eyes and a thin waist as it used to be, but it's still their core definition. Just ignore the women who are famous and focus on the models who are chosen purely for their looks and I bet those women are going to be pretty close to the above description.

That isn't as true as it used to be---there are far more black women and women of color shown more on regular TV, partially due to showrunner Shonda Rimes and her hit shows full of diverse casts. Also, what does "over 30" have to do with anything? You make it sound like being over 30 is over the hill or some mess like that. I also think that the bigger black sisters are cast so that they won't take away the attention from the white women on some shows. That being said, I think comedian/former talk show host/actress Sheri Shepard, Yvette Nicole Brown (from the cult TV fave COMMUNITY) and Octavia Spencer (THE HELP,FRUITVALE STATION) are all beautiful dark-skinned lagre women.


Yes I agree that things are getting better, but it's still a pretty sloooooow process. I mentioned "over 30" because it was (and I think still us) an unwritten rule that once an actress passes 30 she will not be offer or be able to get as many roles as she used to since the majority of roles written for women under 30. Over 30 and it's mostly mother or wife roles.

Sure there are exceptions if you're a famous name, but very few movies feature a female protagonist over the age of 35. I think it's changing now that there are non-theater outlets like TV, Netflix and VOD but traditionally you will not see a movie in theaters with a woman over that age unless it's an Oscar contender or it features Jolie/Diane Lane/Meryl Streep (and more recently, Melissa McCarthy).

As for Octavia, I'm sure that Oscar helped her a lot. Just look at her filmography before The Help.

Don't try to cash in love, that check will always bounce.

reply

That's true, but I don't think it applies to this movie. Bianca was maybe a shade or 2 darker than Lucinda. There wasn't much of a difference.

Excuse me, I gotta go do some black guy stuff....

reply

That's interesting. I thought in other ways, Bianca was more white, in fact when Roscoe's mom mistakenly referred to her as Blanca, to me that was a subtle way of calling her 'white'; blanc means white. I know some people will scoff at this, and debate what it means to act 'black' or 'white', but that's okay. It's what I saw, so in the end he may have chosen a lighter-skinned black woman, but she definitely wasn't less "black" than Bianca.

The actual white girl in this movie was made out to be a complete moron.




You don't choose the soy sauce, the soy sauce chooses you.

reply

[deleted]

Exactly!

reply

Joy is beautiful but truthfully Nicole P is leagues ahead of her.

reply

a woman's attitude can make her very ugly, even Joy Bryant.

Petey Greene: "Wake up, goddammit!"

reply

You have to be kidding me!! Joy Bryant's character was an incredibly shallow, pretentious, wanna-be-celebrity. That became more and more apparent throughout the movie. Towards the end she even told Martin's character to leave his son behind during the race!! And you don't ever talk about your significant other's family like she did! Come on people!--- "It was painful to watch him leave her at the airport" LOL!! I WAS laughing out loud b/c she got exactly what she deserved!

reply

Yeah I saw that too, but my point is that the script forced her character in that direction. Why didn't they make her a controlling nag from the start? They only turned her into a b***h when Roscoe HAD to have a reason to dump her. Anyways, my beffudlement had more to do with why Martin Lawrence would lust over any woman when he has someone like Joy Bryant by his side.

reply

I saw subtle hints of it throughout the movie.

Little comments or facial expressions she made. THe only reason she talked him into going was to exploit his family to get another episode for his show!

His son called her the Boss.

I saw her stuck up ways progress as the film did.

The fact is, the only reason he was with her, was because of the "hollywood super couple" angle.

He was the big time talk show host and she was the trophy celebrity wife. A Hollywood Power Couple!

If he was just Roscoe Jenkins, she would have never even looked his way!

Her "changing" was CERTAINLY not out of the blue.

reply

Binaca and RJ were a terrible match, it's not implying that Bianca was the Devil or anything, she's just insanely controlling, stuck up, jealous, and has her priorities in a totally different place than RJ does. He was in love with Lucinda since he was little, she was a missed opportunity that he never let go of. No one can move on with those kinds of circumstances. And if the OP was suggesting that Bianca's looks could overshadow everything about her, I have one line of text for that:

lololololololololololololololololololololololololol.

------------
Hey Jin! You better not be cheating on me!!

reply

You only had one problem?

reply

When you grow up, you will realize beauty is only skin deep. It is what your eyes want you date, it is what your heart wants that you marry. And what your heart wants is always the most beautiful to you, even if that means you drop your trophy-girl for her.

reply

One problem? Look at the cast, I see a dozen problems, well, when they're smiling.

reply