maid elena


What precisely was the maids problem? She seemed to judge Nick rather harshly for little to no reason. I can only imagine she disapproved of his sexuality. I was disgusted with her.

reply

Don't think it was his sexuality. I think it was his obsequiousness she found off-putting. It was also the fact that Nick was from a middle class background and was elevated to upper class status by virtue of his becoming a permanent houseguest of the Feddens. The help does not typically abide that.

reply

I agree with the OP ; also couldn't stand her. She was extremely harsh towards Nick, possibly because she felt he had ingratiated himself into the family, not totally the case, as he and Toby were good friends at Uni, and in any case not her business. She was even condescending when Nick first entered the home and smirked when he mistook her for Toby's mother. A thoroughly unpleasant woman.

reply

It's as groovergreen says in a similarly themed thread:

She is like the housekeepers of old stately homes; she knows her place, realises that it has a certain dignified status, and is quite snobby about it. So when middle-class Nick comes blundering in and mistakes her for the mistress of the house, she despises him. She regards him as a interloper and a parasite. Nick suspects the same about himself but doesn't really want to face it. He keeps kidding himself that the Feddens need him, that he doesn't know what they'd do without him, even though other people (such as Wani) try to make him see otherwise. In many subtle ways, via cool glances and curt comments, the housekeeper reminds Nick that he will never really fit into this world.

I don't like her and I think she gets Nick wrong when she so brutally dismisses him as "no good". He's just a kid. He's got stuff to learn. If she wants to see "no good" she should be inspecting old Gerald Fedden more carefully. I don't see any redeeming features there ... but because Gerald is rich and posh, he gets away with being a bastard.


Re-watch the scene where Nick first arrives at the Fedden's and mistakes her for the lady of the house... Her disdain for him is palpable.

reply

I applauded her acting but continue to dislike the character.

My late old mother was once a nanny to aristocracy, and can very well recall from her many tales to me and close family in her retirement years, that most certainly not all guests of the family were viewed as interlopers, or suffered behaviour as shown by Elena towards Nick. Manners were observed very closely however, and if the guests knew how to hold a knife and fork! (Pity those who didn't, then my old Mum would have been, as another poster stated, quite snobby about them, discreetly of course). However, in that department, Nick was almost faultless. I say almost - watch carefully when he is first at the dining table with Toby and parents, he was unaware how to eat asparagus, then subtly took a lead from Toby and his father. (My old mother would have noticed that, definitely!) Being young, I felt he simply enjoyed associating with the rich and famous, basking in their shadow. Bear in mind too he had a massive crush on Toby, virtually hero-worshipping the guy, so must have been over the moon to live in the same house, and later, considered one of the family, next best thing to a civil partnership, without the sex!
I agree, for "no good",Elena had many others to use that description of but hardly Nick.
Yes, an excellent point - her disdain when Nick first arrived in the Feddens' drawing room, was indeed palpable, I truly felt for him!

reply

Elena's being given the "last word" on Nick was something I found not only frustrating and out of left field, but poor filmmaking. If she'd felt he was "no good," we should have been shown shots of her looking at him with contempt and disdain; when he was speaking with a lover, or dancing with The Lady, for example. Without any of this, her comment fell flat, IMO, its having no basis.

Nick's having at first mistaken her for the lady of the house was something I found to be charming; it would seem that Elena would have been flattered by his naïveté, rather than scornful of it. That her character delivers the final assessment of Nick's character - one which I simply can't comprehend - does a disservice not only to him, but to the story as a whole.

reply