MovieChat Forums > Black. White. (2006) Discussion > This is NOT an original idea

This is NOT an original idea


I hated this piece of manipulative tripe, which somehow pretended to be a novel and even 'revolutionary' idea. I was doubly irritated when I found many suggesting that used-to-be-comedian Eddie Murphy had 'started' the race reversal thing on a Saturday Night Live skit. Dream on.

Almost 50 years ago (in 1959), when rampant racism was exploding all over the south, a courageous white journalist and World War II veteran from Texas named John Howard Griffin, endured painstaking chemical treatments (he DIDN'T just paint his face) from a dermatologist to darken his skin and make him appear to be black. He succeeded spectacularly.

Griffin then proceeded to travel all over the south, taking loathesome abuse from whites and exposing himself to danger almost every step of the way. He kept a journal and wrote 'Black Like Me,' published in 1961. His book, which was internationally acclaimed, was made into a film in 1964.

Griffin received countless death threats from racists all over the south, but he persisted in getting the truth out about the reality of being black in a white man's world. His first-hand account is still a useful 'bible' for people who want to know what it felt like to be treated as trash, as a third-class citizen because of the colour of his skin.

Nowhere in this, another (groan) @#$%^&* stupid reality show, have the producers even mentioned Griffin, who died in 1980. Disgraceful.

I had a terrible time watching this truly idiotic film, but I wanted to know how it was going to end. And what is the great ultimate message? Learn from each other and understand, and maybe someday racism will disappear. Jeez. How original. Four or five hours and that's the best they can do? That's John Howard Griffin you hear rolling in his grave.

reply

It is obvious by your tone, that you have never experienced the issues that African Americans still deal with on a daily basis and do not want to see anything about it! It is a sad that Black Like Me was made 50 years ago and we still have to deal with the same damn things a white man in blackface did and more. Hopefully one day African Americans will be able to enjoy full Constitutional rights and equal protection under the law. But if individuals like you feel that everything was said in one film and SNL skit, that time will not come any time soon.

reply

You misunderstood my 'tone,' which is very easy to do in written communication.

I'm a white man, and, contrary to what you say, I don't in any way know how African Americans feel, nor do I in any way think that I do.

I despised the show and the whole manipulative nature of it. It was unforgivable that such a profound issue as racism was reduced to the idiotic formula of a reality show. It was equally unforgivable that the program pretended to deal with very sensitive race issues when it was really just another excuse to sensationalize and make money.

I wrote about John Howard Griffin because the people who made the show pretended that race reversal was somehow a 'novel,' even 'revolutionary' idea, when it wasn't. I wanted to remind viewers of that. I did not mean to offend African Americans. Many white people like me don't 'mean' to be racist, but it doesn't matter what we say or do, we get trapped by our own ignorance, insensitivity and the restrictions of language. You've heard it millions times: we 'mean well,' but that doesn't help very much when you're faced with the pain of discrimination everywhere you go.

For the record: I'm a Canadian, not American, and from what I know about the U.S. constitution, it's routinely violated every day by the same U.S. government that pretends it's something sacred.

I wish you well.

reply

Thank you for the point about white american ignorance. It is one of the wonderful makes Canadian a wonderful place to live. I wish my parents had never moved from Toronto!

reply

[deleted]