MovieChat Forums > See No Evil: The Moors Murders (2006) Discussion > Is anyone old enough to remember this ha...

Is anyone old enough to remember this happening?


I was nearly 5 years old at the time & my parents sat me down & told me not to talk to women that I did not know or go anywhere with one. You have to understand that in the 60's you were only told not to go with strange men, no-one could conceive that a woman could do such terrible things to children. My parents would not tell me why they gave me this talking to but I was a bit of a snoop at 5 & could see they were glued to the newspapers (I wasn't allowed to watch the TV, only for cartoons which were few & far between). I naturally eavesdropped & I could hear my parents talking about the little children being buried on the moors. I had nightmares for ages & I couldn't tell them because I wasn't supposed to know. I could read but when I took sneaky peeks at the newspapers my young mind could not process what was written. I can still remember crying in my sleep about the children on the moors.

"I cannot live without my life! I cannot die without my soul".... Heathcliff

reply

That's pretty scary stuff. Where did you live?

http://www.petitiononline.com/bla1ck2/petition.html

reply

I live in Wales but the whole murder trial was so big that it was all over Britain newspapers, you could not pick a newspaper up without being affected. The thing that worried my parents & countless other parents was the fact that Hindley was a woman & as I've said before we were never warned about women only strange men. It was just beyond belief that a woman would enable & assist in the abduction & murder of young children.

I hope they find Keith Bennett for his Mum's sake, he deserves a proper funeral with his Mum & siblings present. Winnie Johnson has never given up hope of finding Keith & I pray she does.

I really did cry for those children & I have never forgotten them.

"I cannot live without my life! I cannot die without my soul".... Heathcliff

reply

I wasnt born when the moors murders happened, I do live in Manchester and know alot about the case though.

Mrs Voorhees is watching you!

reply

mydad was round about your age and lived in manchester at the time, my gran worked at the same place as myra and my grandfather drank at the same pub as ian, this was only found out when they were suspects, this all gave ym dad a unique mentality that he taught me with, which was never ever talk to strangers and if they do talk to you, run and scream, bit much but you see the reasoning

the most eerie tihng about the whole thing that sstill scares the crap out of him is this picture taht was taken in the moors, the kids were burried taht but just not found, and my family were having a picnic, and taking pictures etc, it's really un nerving to look into something like that

reply

I was around 9 years old when this horrible story unfolded.
We lived in the country and the Daily express paper(s) would be delivered to a phone box, my Mother used to send me to collect them and she would be glued to the paper for ages! (Apr/May '66)When the early evening news came on my Father would send us out to play, but we never realised the significance then. Comics at the time would say:'Remember children, never accept lifts from strangers in cars'.

reply

I've met the arresting officer of Ian Brady. After he left the police, he worked for the employment service before retiring.

Plus my dad plays in a band and the singer used to play out with Ian Brady when he was about 8 years old. I asked him what Brady was like as a child and he said he was very quiet. Either way nobody could of predicted what would happen all those years later.

reply

Was this PC Carr? (Arresting officer).

reply

I'm not sure but strange is he looked a lot like John Thaw. I only met him once.

reply

I wasn't born when it all happened, my parents were only 5 at the time. My Grandma worked with Brady, she said he was very strange and kept to himself. I live not far from the moors. I was born in the town where they took John Kilbride from the market. I went to school in the town where they brought the bodies off the moors, they stored the bodies in a local butchers freezer. The house that they murdered the children in is no longer there. Its just a row of houses with one missing. Everytime i go over Saddleworth moors its really creepy. Sounds cruel but the first time i herd all about the story was travelling over the moors, i think i was about 11 or 12. People in the area never talk about it. Its still so sad, it could of been anyones son, daughter or cousin etc. It could of easily been my parents. God knows how many they actually did kill. Sadly Myra and Brady arn't the only 2 serial killers from the area. Doctor Harold Shipman was also from Tameside. He killed over 215 of his patients.

*´¨)
¸.·´¸.·*´¨) ¸.·*¨)
(¸.·´ (¸.·´ Lindsey

reply

further to my earlier post, my mother has since decided to re-marry. She is going to marry the best friend of John Kilbride. My step father was with John the day he was taken, they went to the cinema togther and my step father offered to walk john home, but he said no. He wanted to go to the market and help pack up to earn money. My step father is still in contact with John's family. They never talk about what happened, but i'm sure they will never forget either.

*´¨)
¸.·´¸.·*´¨) ¸.·*¨)
(¸.·´ (¸.·´ Lindsey

reply

Hi Lyndzi,

Would your step-father be a John Ryan by any chance? If so, is he a taxi-driver? When I was in Manchester in March 2008 doing some research about the Moors case, I hailed a cab driven by one John Ryan who said he was with John Kilbride the day Kilbride was picked up from Ashton Market by Brady & Hindley.

I took some "recce" location shots in Wardle Brook Avenue and also at Hollin Brown Knoll on Saddleworth Moor. It would be interesting to hear from you if this is the case.

Best wishes,

Steve Kemp

reply

Hi, no my step father name was David Turner. He passed away two years ago. I recently found out that the house my mother lives in was always my step fathers family's and when John was taken the police searched that house because John and David were best friends. They thought he was hiding there.

reply

I do. I lived in London at the time. Two things strike me. The film did not bring out the extent of Hindley's guilt in entrapping the children. They might have feared an approach from a strange man, but not a friendly woman. This was hinted at but not developed.

Secondly, and I know this sounds nerdish, but I think the film had the cars wrong. I thought Brady/Hindley had a grey Austin A60. My reason is that shortly before David Smith went to the police station, my fellow tenant in Clapham London was asked to account for his movements by police investigating the disappearances of the children. This guy was a company rep visiting shops in the North of England, and he had his call sheets which he had to produce and they went away. Later I read that the police had traced all but a tiny number of Austin A60 drivers by the time that Smith handed himself in. I think the good cop/bad cop view of the investigation shown in the film might have been unfair to some fairly good detectives. But I liked, if that is the word, the film, which has just been shown by TV3 in Ireland.

Or is my memory of events 40 years ago playing tricks?

Kieran Fagan

reply

What you are referring to is the Murderer Raymond Morris who,hot on the heels of the Moors Case (1966)killed two children (girls) in the Cannock Chase area of Derbyshire in 1967!
A nationwide hunt ensued and the police tracked down every known Austin Cambridge (A55) car known.
He was convicted in 1969.
Research a book called NOT The Moors Murders by Pat Molloy you'll see for yourself.Best.

reply

"The film did not bring out the extent of Hindley's guilt in entrapping the children"

The film made it clear from the tape of Leslie Anne Downey that Hindley was present and was part of the murder just as Brady was. The scene of her excited face while Edward Evans was being killed also shows her to be very cold-blooded and Dave Smith says she is worse than Brady. I don't think anyone would come away from that film with the impression that she was anything other than guilty.

reply

Hindley worked in a factory my mother worked in, but not at the same time (Robertson's Jam in Droylsden) relatives of one of the victims live in my neighborhood. I know some people who knew Hindley vaguely as a child. I read in one of the books that Hindley fell off her bike at Crown Point in Denton once (near Gorton) I cycle there all the time and it's really creepy to think I'm retracing her steps. Growing up the case was never talked about, in fact the first time I was aware of it was when Hindley and Brady were mentioned in a Sex Pistols song.

reply

I was born at the back end of the 70's and have been aware of the Moors Murders for quite some years, I have watched See no Evil and many documentaries about it.

Whenever we drive over the Pennines it chills me to the bone, sadly that moor has had an awful aura left over it after what they did, I sort of look at the rugged landscape and imagine Brady and Hindley standing smug over a shallow grave with the wind blowing their hair - my imagination is too vivid for my own good sometimes! I find myself scanning the landscape wondering if I am glancing over where Keith may be buried - and with recent revelations there could be more poor children up there!

reply

I was at a girls secondary school at the time and during the trial the newspaper articles were put up on the classroom walls to point out the dangers of going off in cars with strangers.
That would never be done now but then I suppose that then it was such a shocking and bizarre event people reacted in an extreme way.


Mal,they are starting to damage my calm!

reply

Yes, I was about eleven at the time, and I remember my parents sitting me and my younger sister down and telling us how very important it was not to go off with any person we didn't know, whatever he or she said.

I didn't see this at the time it came out, but I watched it on a re-run channel last night and was stunned by how good it was. The leads were uniformly brilliant - I didn't actually think much of Joanne Froggatt's acting until last night - and more than once I had to remind myself that I was watching a drama and not the real thing. Quite chilling. Horrific to think that for all these years Ian Brady has kept that sadistic silence about where little Keith's remains are. For that alone I would like to see his alleged desire to escape his internment by death to remain unfulfilled.

reply