MovieChat Forums > Suburbicon (2017) Discussion > Grammar in Coen movies.

Grammar in Coen movies.


I just watched Burn After Reading, and it appears the Coens are trying to give their viewers grammar lessons. Several times in the scene where the HardBodies gym custodian gives the CD to Pitt and McDormand, he says, "It was just lying there." And in response to him, Pitt uses the verb "to lie" correctly, too. Reviewers have complained that the movie's premises are unrealistic, but to me what's unrealistic is that CD scene, that correct use of a verb I've heard and read misused thousands of times by talking heads and intelligentsia that should know better.

For the majority of us, the last time we took a grammar lesson was in high school. We could use a refresher or two before the verb "to be" disappears from our language. Movie writers, use the "F" word as you like, but place it in a correctly conjugated sentence. I do!

Thank you, Coen brothers. Please keep it up.

reply

wat

reply

Is this a criticism, or not? At first it seems so, but then, you thank the Coens.

Just because they say it right doesn't mean that they know it's right. Most people use the phrase "(Person's name) and me" in every case, never using "(Person's name) and I," but sometimes, they are correct.

reply

way to make me think they were getting Kelsey Grammar in on the gang. What a great way to start the day then having your hopes raised then crushed.

But on a more serious note, I think a movie with Tom Hanks and Kelsey Grammar would be amazing.

And yes,I know my opinion is dumb, but just humour my idea.

reply

You are the one person in the world that sees the word grammar and thinks of the actor.

reply

So am I the only one who thought of the Nelly song?

(heh heh just kidding.........)

reply

wat


i think you meant... "twat"?

reply

Whaaaat the hell are you on about?

reply

KELSEY GRAMMAR OR HOWEVER IT'S SPELLED SAYS THAT HE'S A FREAK ABOUT CORRECTLY USING GRAMMAR SO IT'S FUNNY YOU THOUGHT OF HIM.

reply

I SHOUT WITH MY HANDS, NOT WITH MY MOUTH.

"Who do you think you are, Bill Clinton? You're a comptroller!"

reply

i can shout with my butt!

reply

LOUD NOISES!

reply

I DON'T KNOW WHAT WE'RE YELLING ABOUT!

And I have no clue what the OP was talking about.




Never defend crap with 'It's just a movie'
http://www.youtube.com/user/BigGreenProds

reply

If every character in every movie spoke with perfect grammar, we'd all die of boredom within a month. Thank God there are NO RULES in dialog.

The way to succeed is to never quit.

reply

[deleted]