MovieChat Forums > Butterfly on a Wheel (2007) Discussion > Why do you think Judy cheated on Tom?

Why do you think Judy cheated on Tom?

posted 9 years ago by sarizonana
2 replies | jump to latest

Its clear Neil did it for lust and thought it would be an affair without consequences but Judy ?

I imagine she did it because she felt abandoned. Tom was a guy who went often to Hunting trips leaving her slone and actually when he meets with his son didn't seem to loving.
I could also guess he was a violent husband, otherwise he wouldn't have come up with such an evil plan of revenge.
He would have planned something harmless to make Neil suffer a bitt but his plan was something that only an evil person could come up with.

I wished they have let us see why Judy cheated on Tom and that way truly see both sides of the stories the cheaters and the ones who were cheated on.

[–] TakeTwoTheyreSmall 8 years ago

Who said it was Tom's plan? Who discovered the affairs first, and who contacted whom first? Abby is psycho, any way you look at it, which becomes perfectly clear at the end when she explains her motives to Neil. The meeting with Tom's son may have been contrived, as well. It certainly added to Neil's state of confusion.

Life is tough, but it's tougher when you're stupid.

[–] sarizonana 8 years ago

Well no one said it lol but i came up with conclusion because Tom always looked so in control and his anger looked pretty psychotic when he confronted Niel and Judy Together.

Why would he would make Tom kill his wife if he didn't plan the whole thing nd some other stutff he said makes me believe he pkanned everything.

At the hotel room when he tocuhes abby it like he was really pissed that only him could have planned such an evil game, when he tells abby great performance and when they are at te van waiting for Tom to get to the clock and also atvthat pointbhe tells Neil forvthe first time be a man.

All these things are hints Tom wass the matermind in the whole thing.