MovieChat Forums > Lipstick Jungle (2008) Discussion > Andrew McCarthy Past his Peak

Andrew McCarthy Past his Peak


Come on girls, who else was excited to hear Andrew McCarthy was in Lipstick Jungle? And who else was disappointed to see that the Kingdom Hospital Andrew McCarthy of not so long ago has weathered significantly?

reply

[deleted]

Amen

reply

he is not the "Mr Big" material they want him to play. wrong guy cast.

reply

[deleted]

Actually, there quite a few other actors that could have done a much better job.
I was, and still am disappointed with his performance.
I honestly don't think he's right for the part at all.

Well, tattooed lovers they don't like to reminisce

reply

I agree - I don't see the appeal in him at all, never have.

reply

Don't like the character, still LOVE Andrew. What a hottie...better with age.

reply

I still love Andrew!! Something about his smile even my 11 year old thinks he's HOT!!

reply

[deleted]

he is charming and sexy but I, too, believe that they should have picked someone else ... I remember when I saw Chris's Noth as Mr Big for the first time ... you really believed that he was this big shot, rich, charming man. Everything from his posture to his speech helped towards that end.

I don't get that vibe from Joe. I just don't believe this guy had all this money and power. I keep trying to fall for the convention and then my mind goes: He's just an actor playing a part.

ask the spokesperson, I don't have a brain

reply

I never liked him, nor I thought a women like Victory would dig him either.

reply

Actually I think he does a great job. You know what they say opposites attract! Come on lets look at Charlotte on Sex and The City and her second husband! Lets face it he is much better looking than that guy! Regardless I can remember watching him in movies when I was a little girl! He was hot then and still a hottie now.

reply

I never could understand what Charlotte saw in that guy.

reply

ITA with loredanaghidarcea. Chris Noth just have this aura of a real Mr. Big while this guy does not have. Yeah, he maybe cute in his young years but he just does not fit into a millionaire person role. something in him says he is jut acting, not believable at all.

reply

[deleted]

I think Andrew is great (and I'm someone Kirby's age). He was looking at Victory last night and just tilted his head to the side. It was incredibly endearing and was perfect.

reply

That subtle look, that smile, that slight tilt of the head - all classic Andrew McCarthy...these are the very things that endeared him to many female fans during the 80s....

And still adore him after all these years...

He portrays a different kind of rich playboy (almost an antithesis to Big of SiTC, who is atypical strong, masculine, tall, dark & handsome-type)...

Instead we get an innocence & vulnerability....AM still has a lot of cuteness to offer after all these years & enjoy seeing him again on the screen.

reply

I enjoy watching Andrew McCarthy in this role, and I don't want anyone else playing Joe. I find Andrew sexy and endearing.

reply

As a teenager, I adored Andrew McCarthy, he had the charm and looks
that I thought Rob Lowe lacked. He is the best part of Lipstick Jungle.

BTW, does the book expand on his character? Is the book worth reading?

reply

The book doesn't really expand on his character, but it is worth reading. I actually like it more than the TV show.

reply

Thanks, I will read the book, then.

I hope this show stays on the air. It's the
only hour drama I watch. I hate all of those
CSI shows.

reply

Andrew McCarthy is gorgeous and he's perfect for the role! I love his sweet, coy smile and charming demeanor. Too hot!

reply

[deleted]

Well, as a teenie of the 80s I have to say that I have always thought Andrew McCarthy to be absolutely hot! In fact, I think he's even better to watch now than he was back then. He was always great though. Even 20-odd years ago!

reply

Andrew is way past his prime. He was adorable in the 80's but not so much anymore.

reply

You're wrong. He is not past his peak. He's better than ever. Sure, his looks have changed from the young innocent looking boy in the 80s to a mature sexy man. WE ALL GET OLDER and nobody is immune to "weathering." Andrew has that endearing smiling and blue eyes that are irresistable. He has a lot to offer as an actor. I'm happy to see he's doing movies and acting in the career he enjoys. I hate comments like yours that indicate actors are past their peak. Just because you get older in the business, it does not mean you are past your peak. Andrew is a great actor with intensity and would love to see more of him on TV and films. I'm sick of actors who are overly Hollywood. It's refreshing to see veteran actors like Andrew who in my opinion are REAL actors who enjoys their craft and not those overly publicized actors.

reply

You misunderstand, though perhaps I wasn't very clear. When I said he was past his peak, I meant as far as looks are concerned. I don't care if that sounds vain, he was hot at one point and now he's old-looking, and I know that doesn't make him any less of a talented actor but it's still true.

reply

[deleted]

I have never seen him in anything else.. i find him totally not sexy at all and he does not convince me at all either! I think there would of been better people to fit the role..

reply

[deleted]

To be honest, I didn't think he was all that in Pretty in Pink. I saw him as an adult first before I saw any of his bratpack films, I had to check and double check the cast list before I believed it was really him. I liked him about 10 years ago in Kingdom Hospital.

reply

[deleted]