MovieChat Forums > Hana yori dango (2005) Discussion > Out of all 3 of the Hana Yori Dango dra...

Out of all 3 of the Hana Yori Dango dramas which is best?


Out of the 3 dramas based on Hana Yori Dango which one do you think is the best?

Your no bunny till some bunny loves you

reply

Japanese version no contest

reply

Japanese version, all the way. I tried watching the Korean one, but it just wasn't the same. Makino and Domyoji were amazing.

reply

i love makino and doumyouji

reply

Japanese version definitely and i want to add that is the best asian drama i've seen so far.

reply

I've only seen the Japanese one, but it's pretty good. I'm not a big fan of dramatic love stories and HYD managed to be silly, romantic & sweet so I liked it. I wouldn't say it's my favorite drama ever, but it is certainly polished and well-executed.

You know, this thread got me thinking and I think so far my favorite Jdorama/mystery might be Trick. It's certainly flawed, but I enjoyed it a lot.

Sokka: My first girlfriend turned into the moon.
Zuko: That's rough, buddy.

reply

This version, the Korean version is by far the best in my book, the Japanese was kind of all right, the Taiwanese was great too, I loved the take on the romantic scenes and the music. Still all these version didn't pick up on some of the stuff that was in the manga, like the number of times Dom and Makino were attempting to have sex.

reply

Meteor Garden was the best
Hana Yori Dango was a close second; it did have the best version of Rui/Lei/Ji Hoo
Boys Over Flowers is last, had the best clothes though, at least for the guys.

Clark Kent + Lois Lane 4ever
DC Can Suck It

reply

I agree the same as you listed, Meteor Garden is my personal favorite.

reply

I've only seen the J-drama and I'll try Meteor Garden soon. But I know what it's like with the different country remakes,, the first one you watch always ends up your favourite.

I can't imagine another Makino or Tsukasa.

Shinjirarenai!!

Another brilliant post Steinberg...

reply

Well this one and then the Korean adaptation, even the Chinese one.

The Taiwanese one made me cringe, I don't get it, the acting was terrible, and that guys hair just bothered me. 😕 At least the dudes in the other three coincidentally all had great hair, sorry! 😫

Honey, you should see me in a crown

reply