MovieChat Forums > A Crime (2006) Discussion > Was he really the killer? (Spoilers)

Was he really the killer? (Spoilers)


There were 2 scenes in the movie where it was made to look like Roger could have actually been the killer, the scene where he gets the jacket and the one where he puts on the ring. I'm glad they didn't go into much more detail, it would have made the movie go from simply boring to absurd beyond belief. In a good movie I'd watch it again to go over the details, this movie didn't get me interested enough for a repeat. I gave it a 4.

reply

[deleted]

I think he is the killer. The red jacket and the ring both indicate that.
Although I am not a big fan of the sheer conicidence. But that's the only way to set our love birds free. BTW, Karma is really a bitch.

reply

Well, yes....it IS strongly implied that Roger is the killer.

...which might actually be one of the weaker points of the movie; what are the odds that she picks him, from literally thousands of cab drivers...?!

reply

I think he was

first when she gives him the red jacket, you can see he's upset, and the ofcourse the ring in his car




When there's no more room in hell, The dead will walk the earth...

reply

That's absolutely nonsense to me. I don't think he was the killer. The point is that she is a monster, she ruined the guy and then killed him just to get what she wanted and he had not done anything to her...
And Vincent - he was a complete idiot, the guy couldn't think straight, he was ready to kill every taxi driver wearing a red jacket on the planet.
And if you think that fate brought Alice and the killer together this is absolutely insane. So she picks a random taxi driver and it turns out that he is indeed the killer? Like it is so improbable it just might happen? Give me a break.
Keitel reacts this way because Alice's behaviour is irrational, he feels that something is not quite right, that is why he asks her about the jacket. She says she loves red but she is not wearing anything red.
By the way how does she have money for booze? She doesn't appear to be working anywhere. And where does she got the money for the jacket and the ring? How does she pay her rent?She is obviously not a nine-to-five person?


Women are like deer - You can't just charge in, you gotta stalk 'em...

reply

What Derirre says- thouigh the film's idiotic tendency to show that he may be tyhe killer aggravates me to no end.

myspace.com/bankrupteuropeans

Coz lifes too short to listen to Madlib

reply

If he indeed was the killer who wore the red jacket wouldn't that indicate that he likes red jackets and be glad about it receiving one as a gift? Why would a killer be upset about a red jacket?

reply

I could've sworn he called her Amanda at one point.
They were in the hotel about to make love and he says ' I love you Amanda '
That was weird...
So I'm thinking it's a possibility!

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]