is this a real docu?

Hi Filmzrule,

You confirmed my answer to the original question. Is This a real Documentary? I answered the poster, no, which you confirm by calling it a docudrama. I'm not sure what there is to argue in that? Even the title is misleading. In Sin He found Salvation. That's a contradiction in terms when using "Salvation" in the Biblical way it's used here. Futhermore Wikipedia is more useful as a starting point to reference other data than it is an accurate portrayal of facts to depend on. The ultimate source of what went on after Fish took the children was Fish himself, so we never will be certain of anything other than the story Fish told, and the condition of remains found. The man was insane. Newspaper accounts have always been sensationalized, we have no audio record of Fish confessing, and even if we had, nothing to compare that to since voice recognition wasn't available then, hence nothing to verify what the police wrote down and what they didn't.

The main gist of your second post to me seems to be an attempt to derail my opinion by showing the disparity of my meager research as compared to your in depth knowledge. As I've already stated, given complete access to every record kept about the man and his deeds can hardly make you an expert since these are inadequate in the first place.

Since you in fact term this a docudrama your query as to what facts are wrong is completely redundant. I'll never know - but then you won't either. My main complaint about this effort remains. I'm not arguing facts here, I'm arguing that the way in which these facts were portrayed was sleazy and offensive and that this was done intentionally.