MovieChat Forums > Alone (2007) Discussion > Ploy wasnt altogether bad, I think! (spo...

Ploy wasnt altogether bad, I think! (spoilers)

posted 13 years ago by siriusblack320-1
1 reply | jump to latest

I dont want to justify Pim'death at the hands of Ploy but the way Pim's behaviour changed towards her sister after meeting a guy was definitely a huge setback for ploy.In the beginning the girls are shown living happily.Their mother is also not worried.But just for a boy ,pim completely neglects her sister.And when wee drew pim alone,how would you feel if you were ploy? That's disheartning and on top of that pim called ploy an appendage!In her emotions and despair ,ploy killed pim but surely she felt guilty afterwards.Her mother too stopped talking to her.Just because of a guy.the relationship turned sour...any opinions??

[–] dragonfist_007 12 years ago

Yup i agree with you, Ploy wasn't that bad.... Pim didnt exactly ignore her... I think more than tht its just the people around them made Ploy what she is.... when both sisters were young.. most people like pim not ploy ( this ploy mentions at the end of the film) i wonder why coudnt Wee still live with Ploy after all this guy has been living with ploy and having a relationship with her for ages (although he didnt know it was ploy and not pim) ....

the mother although i agree was pissed off with ploy for killing her sister...she should have atleast in at a later stage encourage ploy to become a better person and being a mother she should have seen clearly how people preferred pim and not ploy.....this type of unfortunate favoritism can have extreme mental side effects on anyone who is completely igonored in the family for no fault of theirs...