MovieChat Forums > Thanmathra (2005) Discussion > Which is better THANMATHRA or KAAZCHA ?

Which is better THANMATHRA or KAAZCHA ?


Hi I saw Thanmathra yestarday and thought just see how its going' on at IMDB.
OK. Which is more better Thanmathra or Kaazcha. My opinion:-THANMATHRA
It has got all -Technology and art. Nice camera-which does not prick eyes,nice music-especially the first song its like a cool breeze,Excellent acting by ALL-its like everybody worth an award,and BRILLIANT direction-Blessy 5 star for that.

For me kaazcha caused a lot itching-Unwanted scenes,overacting by Mammooty, unnecessary songs,unnecessary characters and of all I blamed Blessy for that because Mammokka is a great actor-but only with a good director. But Now BLESSY is really agood director and an excellent legacy tho Indian Cinema.

reply

Hope this does not turn out to be another one of "Who is better, Mammooty or Mohanlal?" debates.

;)

reply

Undoubtedly Thanmathra. Kazhcha is a very simple theme told in a simple manner. Thanmathra is very complex. But Blessy managed to execute the theme quite convincingly.

Kazhcha is child's play compared to Thanmathra.

reply

ofcourse Thanmathra is better than kazhcha, it is one of the best in malayalam movie history.....

reply

No doubt Thanmathra is better than Kazhcha

reply

Amen to that ...THANMATHRA...really exhibits the Wizardry of the GURU of acting...ie..MOHANLAL...and im not saying this to agitate MAMMOOTY fans..as i worship him too...Just see his old movie.."THANIAVARTHANAM"...JUST MATCHLESS

reply

Thanmatra has got more substance than Kazhcha. And Mohanlal is a wizard.

reply

thanmathra hands down.

but that doesnt mean it isnt flawed. the acting was excellent and we get to see what mohanlal is really capable of but the the way his mind just deteriorated within the span of a few days/weeks was just plain dumb.

overlooking that its my fav malayalam movie of the last 10 years.

reply

His mind didnt deteriorate in some weeks, his son was on 10th grade when he has his first symtoms of that condition and by the time he dies, his son is an IAS personel;)
The movie is just outstanding..one of the best ever in Malayalm.
Most dont know that the story is by a legend in Malayalm cinema, unfortunalty not in this world now

reply

vineeth ya even i saw the name of the legend Shri.Padmarajan's name metioned in the movie.....but i dont know how his name came....could you tell something on that .

reply