MovieChat Forums > This Is England (2007) Discussion > Was Banjo a good guy really? (spoilers)

Was Banjo a good guy really? (spoilers)

posted 11 years ago by sb-94
6 replies | jump to latest

During the scene in which Combo is battering Milky, Banjo restrains Shaun, and in my opinion he's protecting Shaun. He knows if Shaun tries to stop Combo (who has turned psychotic) Combo will batter him.
Also after the beating, Banjo is heard saying to Combo 'all day we've had to sit and listen to this, we want out b!tch).
So was Banjo a good guy really?

[–] westside_wiipa 11 years ago

He was a fcking nazi, no he wasnt a good guy. Plus if he would have been he should have stopped Combo when he started beating Milky.

[–] tylerdanielblack 11 years ago

No, Banjo was the most despicable character in the entire film against which we could measure Combo's redeeming qualities which is why This Is England 86 feels like such an utter betrayal of the film.

The Dude Abides...

[–] Pania8407 11 years ago

He was holding Shaun because he didn't want Shaun interferring with the beating.

[–] fairy_depp 10 years ago

Exactly.. Although Shaun was much younger he was angry enough to get in the way of the attack on Milky. He wasn't protecting Shaun, he was keeping him out of the way so that the attack could carry on.

[–] drakeyequation 11 years ago

'all day we've had to sit and listen to this, we want out b!tch).

Um, no. He says: "I want some of this. We want our bit." i.e. he wanted a piece of the action. That's what prompts Combo to bottle him. Banjo was a vile thug in the movie. I haven't seen the TV series, but by all accounts, I've heard his character was butchered into some kind of lovable oaf.

[–] BeOneOfUs 9 years ago

Not in the film, no way.
He wanted to keep beating Milky after Combo had already almost killed him!