MovieChat Forums > Premonition (2007) Discussion > ''If I let Jim die, is that the same thi...

''If I let Jim die, is that the same thing as killing him?''


Good question. My answer would be no. Any other opinions?

ABC, 123, that girl wore her jeans like me. I bet she's mad, 'cos I look fab. Hahaha, JACK MY SWAG.

reply

legally speaking allowing somebody to die when you can save them is depraved indifference homicide, but of course it's very dependant on circumstance
morally speaking, it's a whole lot more complex and that's even without the time travel/premonitions thrown in

~~~
"I don't care, I'm still free. You can't take the sky from me..."

reply

[deleted]

WELL LETS SEE WE ALL KNOW THAT KIDS ARE DYEING OF STARVATION IN AFRICA AND OTHER PLACES BUT YET MOST DO NOTHING! ARE THOSE WHO DO NOTHING RESPONSIBLE?
SHE WOULD BE GUILTY IN HER OWN MIND AND EVERYDAY SHE WOULD PROB REGRET IT BUT AS A LEGAL STANDPOINT PROB NOT, THEY WOULD HAVE TO PROVE SHE KNEW AND IM SURE AFTER SHE TELLS THEM SHE TIME TRAVELED THROUGHOUT THE WEEK FROM DIFFERENT DAYS TO THE NEXT THE ONLY PLACE SHES GONNA GO IN BACK IN THE KOOKOO WARD AND PROB THINK SHE HAD SOMETHING TO DO WITH THE DEATH, LIKE SEEN ON SATURDAY..

reply

[deleted]

My cousin killed his self cause wife told him to. We talked with police, it's not a crime to know about a suicide before it happens in NC

reply

[deleted]