MovieChat Forums > En la cama (2007) Discussion > Has anyone seen the remake of this ("Roo...

Has anyone seen the remake of this ("Room in Rome")? Which is better?


So, to those of you who have seen both this and the remake HabitaciĆ³n en Roma (2010), which did you prefer? Which one do you think ultimately has more spirit and heart in the relationship?

EDIT: Okay, having just seen this version, I have to say I like the remake lots more. It was elegant where this felt shabby, it was enthusiastic where this felt solemn, it was romantic where this felt stoic, and above all, it was happy, where this, ultimately, felt sad.

This one didn't put a smile on my face, it didn't make me believe in love or fate or the extraordinary---the other one did. So, one thing's for sure, this proves the case that remaking a movie is not necessarily a bad thing. I love it actually, because I love to compare originals with remakes. What do you all think?

Please excuse typos/funny wording; I use speech-recognition that doesn't always recognize!

reply