MovieChat Forums > Crossing the Line (2007) Discussion > A very compelling, intelligent, and well...

A very compelling, intelligent, and well spoken man


I was stationed in Japan in the Navy when Charles Jenkins turned himself in. I remember reading an article that came out about him soon after and I seriously considered trying to go meet him in person because I found the idea of a westerner telling of decades of life in North Korea to be fascinating. The article I read outright stated Jenkins was of below average intelligence. That he was poor at speaking I had hoped they make some kind of movie about this, though I thought it a bummer he's not well spoken enough to really get into much detail. Never did I know about this film that came out while I was still in Japan.

My job, my life centered around North Korea for those few years. I actually had the opportunity to set foot in North Korea, though only a couple steps, while visiting the DMZ bungalows.

This documentary almost completely satiates much of my initial curiosity, but also leaves me wanting to ask Dresnok or others 100 more questions.

I was blown away by how well spoken and what a personality this guy is. It's fascinating how American he is, how honest he is about his past, and how entirely engaging he is, yet simultaneously is a product and flag waiver of North Korea.

I get some of the angry comments here. Yes, he is a traitor. Yes, he's not a sympathetic character as he enjoyed luxury while millions starved. But you still must notice what a personality he is. You want to say, oh he'd be nobody back in America. I don't believe that. Whether through necessity, or always in him, he's such a presence that I can't believe he's not a politician. He could easily be a senator or a governor. He carried this documentary. And I think it's obvious the documentary makers knew this.

reply

I'm just fascinated that he was permitted to speak so frankly in the documentary. Or really, that BBC was allowed to film it at all.

I understand a certain propaganda value for the DPRK government of a Westerner saying "Hey, I'm happy here" but it's not like he cast them in a completely flattering light. Up until the discussion of Charles Jenkins at the end, he speaks pretty honestly about his experiences, which are far from wonderful.

reply