Rather well-researched


I just saw this film last night. I was surprised when I looked at the birthplaces of the writer, screenwriter, director, etc. that none of them were born in Pennsylvania. I grew up in the coal mining region of Pa. and I think many aspects of this film are historically accurate. Kids often worked in the mines, and the smaller ones often had to crawl in narrow crevices, like the character Sara did in the opening scene. In the beginning where one of the workers had a canary in a cage is also correct for mining practices because canaries were used to detect the presence of dangerous gases (I think if it died that was a sign for the miners to get out immediately). Even the town's name of "Addytown" strikes a resemblance to the names of patch towns throughout PA.

One of the few things I questioned was why the Tunny childrens' family lived in such a large house (I mean in 1913). A house that size would be for the people in the company who had high positions, not the typical miners. Miners usually lived in extreme poverty in tiny houses.

reply

Kids often worked in the mines, and the smaller ones often had to crawl in narrow crevices, like the character Sara did in the opening scene.


That was Mary, not Sarah. Sarah's the teenager.

Aang: It's Sparky Sparky Boom Man!
Homer: No beer and no TV make Homer...something something.

reply

The movie was very cliche' and cheesy... however I agree about the historical accuracy of using children for work and other tidbits.

This is why they created child labor laws and child abuse laws folks! back in the day children had no rights. they were seen more as property than human beings.

"Life is good I can't compain... I mean I could but no one's listening."

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]