MovieChat Forums > Bloody Mary Discussion > Is there a decent Bloody Mary movie out ...

Is there a decent Bloody Mary movie out there???


This movie was not what I expected. I was hoping for something along the lines of Candyman (the first one). With all the Bloody Mary movies out there has anyone seen one that was actually good and scary?

reply

Urban Legends: Bloody Mary is.................OK. I'm not going to say it's "good" but it's a semi-fun way to kill 90 minutes.

Or there's the Bloody Mary episode of Supernatural, on the first season DVD...



"When you have a fat friend, there are no see-saws. Only catapults."

reply

Funny I was just gonna ask this.

I just hope someday they can create a true Bloody Mary movie, and not a movie where "Mary" is someone who died 30 years ago (this movie and Urban Legends). The story has so much potential to be created into possibly the scariest movie ever, but it needs a good writer and director.

It'll come...someday

reply

Candyman.

reply

[deleted]

This is the best Bloody Mary film I've seen and I've seen many now that weren't as good as this. People are being too hard on this one.

Your chains are still mine, you belong to me! - The Phantom Of The Opera

reply

[deleted]

if you type 'bloody mary' into youtube, you'll find some decent short 20-40 minute movies. It may actually work better that way.

Usually movies based on an unsolved mystery (JFK, Zodiac, Gustave, Hoffa etc.) have a diffucult time ending it since there is no real life resolution.

Bloody mary kind of falls into the subject of unsolved mystery. It is an unproven urban legend.

You can believe that since the legend has been around for so long and so popular, there might be some truth to it. Or you can believe that since many have tried it with nothing happening, theres so many different variations, and there's never been conclusive evidence, it's fake.

But the trouble is that how do you remain faithful to the source material and end the story? Cant really kill or get away from bloody mary. I saw a 2 part movie on youtube today done well. 2 girls chant mary worth three times into a mirror. Nothing happens at first but theres a lot of small scares (doors and things moving, things showing up in windows and mirrors). The one girl goes home and they are both home alone and paranormal things happen. Theres not a traditional ending, it's assumed bloody mary 'gets' both girls.

reply

No movie, but there's an episode of Supernatural called Bloody Mary that's quite good.

reply