I hated Suicide Club, but I loved this movie!!!
I had heard about "Noriko's Dinner Table" a long time ago but held off on watching it just because I didn't really like "Suicide Club". I'm not a big fan of horror movies, and perhaps that had something to do with it, but I just thought the acting in suicide club was bad, and the whole film just felt poorly put together and ultimately quite campy. (Sorry to the Suicide Club fans, I know a lot of you guys are passionate, but that's just how I felt...)
Turns out holding off on watching this was a bad idea. I saw it the other night and was mesmerized from beginning to end. I was expecting a horror movie, but Noriko's Dinner Table was not a horror movie. I don't know if that skewed my perception a little bit since I didn't have high expections (not liking Suicide Club and knowing this was made as a prequel to that), and was expecting something completely different, so I watched the movie again, and still loved it!
The performances were great, the direction by Sono was superb, and perhaps because I wasn't looking for answers to questions raised from the first film I was able to see it in a different light than "Suicide Club" fans. I usually prefer more intimate stories and characters, and this movie certainly provided that in abundance. Its composition kind of reminded me of one of my other favorite films, "Talk to Her" by Pedro Almodovar, in the way it unfolded the story from the different characters' perspectives one at a time. Moreover, I was pretty blown away by the emotional resonance of the film - I wasn't expecting anything like that. Whereas Suicide Club was a very visceral experience, this film's impact was much more psychological. The stuff between Noriko/Mitsuko and Yuka/Yoko were the best parts for me - Yuriko Yoshitaka is a great actress! (Those who liked her in this movie should check out her performance in "Adrift in Tokyo" - Hilarious!).
Anyways, I'm rambling... my point is this: freakin great film!!! Loved it!