MovieChat Forums > Noriko no shokutaku (2006) Discussion > I hated Suicide Club, but I loved this m...

I hated Suicide Club, but I loved this movie!!!


I had heard about "Noriko's Dinner Table" a long time ago but held off on watching it just because I didn't really like "Suicide Club". I'm not a big fan of horror movies, and perhaps that had something to do with it, but I just thought the acting in suicide club was bad, and the whole film just felt poorly put together and ultimately quite campy. (Sorry to the Suicide Club fans, I know a lot of you guys are passionate, but that's just how I felt...)

Turns out holding off on watching this was a bad idea. I saw it the other night and was mesmerized from beginning to end. I was expecting a horror movie, but Noriko's Dinner Table was not a horror movie. I don't know if that skewed my perception a little bit since I didn't have high expections (not liking Suicide Club and knowing this was made as a prequel to that), and was expecting something completely different, so I watched the movie again, and still loved it!

The performances were great, the direction by Sono was superb, and perhaps because I wasn't looking for answers to questions raised from the first film I was able to see it in a different light than "Suicide Club" fans. I usually prefer more intimate stories and characters, and this movie certainly provided that in abundance. Its composition kind of reminded me of one of my other favorite films, "Talk to Her" by Pedro Almodovar, in the way it unfolded the story from the different characters' perspectives one at a time. Moreover, I was pretty blown away by the emotional resonance of the film - I wasn't expecting anything like that. Whereas Suicide Club was a very visceral experience, this film's impact was much more psychological. The stuff between Noriko/Mitsuko and Yuka/Yoko were the best parts for me - Yuriko Yoshitaka is a great actress! (Those who liked her in this movie should check out her performance in "Adrift in Tokyo" - Hilarious!).

Anyways, I'm rambling... my point is this: freakin great film!!! Loved it!

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I feel the opposite way, I thought Suicide Club was awesome, but found this to be well....boring as hell to be blunt (I mean did it really need to be over 2 and a half hours long?)

back in 98 I did a titty comedy for Skinemax. Sex Camp, ya remember it?

reply

I saw Suicide Club a few years ago and thought it was good enough, but nothing special. Recently I've been watching Sono's other films though, including this one, and I've found that they're much much better. Noriko's Dinner Table is amazing, as is Hazard and Strange Circus, and I can't wait to see Love Exposure.

Where's my elephant?

reply

Wow so you started at the bottom of the barrel, and are working your way up to his best movie!

reply

Noriko's Dinner Table is a superior film to Suicide Club. I am fan of Sono's films, and I have seen most of his films that are available in the US (Hazard, Exte, Strange Circus, Suicide Club, Love Exposure, and Noriko's Dinner Table).

Along time ago, I really enjoyed Suicide Club (to some extent I do still). However, I think as time has passed, and I have seen more of Sono's work and see how he has a full grasp on his writing talent and camera ability---he is amazing. I recently looked at Suicide Club (recently--like today) and it just seemed really unfocused. Almost like different stories smashed together with no real relation to the other. Now, what I find great about Sono--especially in Love Exposure and Noriko's is that he has this great ability to intertwine stories together and make them relate to one another. Also, he brings such strong characters that can really affect the viewer. I love Sono's work because I always feel a sadness when I'm watching his films and I believe his movies after Suicide Club is his best work. I happen to think Noriko's Dinner Table and Love Exposure are his best films because they both have a focus and lead us on a journey of the inner thoughts and feelings of the characters.

reply

I loved Suicide Club and I finally just caught up with Noriko's Dinner Table. This is a superior film by far. A great character study piece - acting and direction was superb, great story, just loved it. I love movies that trigger an emotional connection within me and I can't believe how well this movie did that.

reply

how anyone can prefer this to suicide club is beyond me...the acting is as dull and flat as the story itself. lets see, the family renting service was a pointless subplot that did nothing but pad out the already overlong running time. Suicide club had me hooked straight from the start because of its emotional intensity and awesome charecters...NDT "was" the exact opposite. Sion sono did a great job of lowering my expectations for any of his other movies....

reply

[deleted]

Agree completely, I think Sono has improved because he's found his true voice as a cutting edge director, Noriko is a masterpiece, Suicide Club feels a bit amateurish in comparison.

I loved it as well and gave it a 10, can't believe it's taken me so long to discover Sono, I own almost everything by him now, he's easily one of the best directors of his generation (and I've yet to see Love Exposure, which I've heard such great things about, but I'm holding it off until I'm I can get past the hour hour running time).

reply

I did get the feeling from the first movie that I was missing something, its only so much that I can get from the movie. I thought the movie was giving us a explanation behind the Manual of Suicide also published in Japan a few years before the movie.

Lack of connectedness in life, turned into a feeling of connectedness in death and after death (with the stitched together skin). The point came across rather strongly towards the end if people hadn't caught on yet. The use of media (and internet to which was used as a way for a group to claim as being the ones behind it) allowed a scapegoat to take the blame for the suicide club, a group of glamour rock styled rapist/murders taking all the credit for it when they weren't smart enough to come up with a cult. Internet was only used as a means to end whether it be to actually bring together people in death or bring lies to the forefront because thats what everyone wants. Someone to blame.

When the true blame lies with parents who don't seem to take a interest in the lives of their children. A huge devide between parents, teachers, education board and teenagers, fostered by a rather strict and harsh Japanese culture that values independence & strict adherence with little to no creativity or room for rebellion. We sometimes have to rebel to come up with ideas on how to achieve our goals or improve a system that doesn't foster viable ways of getting the success we want. Sometimes its not even success but the social gratification we want for achievement. Facing a problem is always the more difficult option, its easy to see the problem after its to late to fix it.

The craziness we see from Japan is a rather small subset of the true japan. Over there, there are many topics that are seen as out of bounds for discussion. So we get a continuous ignoring of the problem until it goes away.
As a problem gets ignored it festers, and juvenile violence in the form of gangs is something of a modern phenomena & we can see this issue is growing.
When a system is designed to be from the ground up about the end goal and not the journey we all take to get there, young people get ignored & so they themselves try to ignore their own problems.
When they raise important questions they are treated like what they say doesn't matter, so the system favours itself. If that problem is much worse for adults, its because they get taught not to be invested in anything that isn't in the pursuit of career, self-discipline, perfect your role and never going out of line lest the punishment be severe. Until you decide whats important its all going to go to the ultimate end.. the suicide club in the films view.

Maybe this movie will help answer the questions I have, I didn't know there was a sequel of sorts. Who are behind the suicide club and what is their true purpose, what does it mean by are you connected with yourself, and how does suicide relate to this? What is our role in life? What is our connection between family and other people? I'm finding it more interesting to think about.

reply