MovieChat Forums > I'm Reed Fish (2006) Discussion > Casting Failure ?

Casting Failure ?

posted 11 years ago by allen_shezar
1 reply | jump to latest

The Plot was alright I guess but can anyone really buy it with those actors ?

Don't get me wrong most of the leads are solid actors and have shown some great performances in other movies but Jay Baruchel dating Alexis Bledel and then actually cheating on her for Schuyler Fisk ?? seriously ?? surely looks aren't the most important if it comes to such issues but here the difference in atractiveness of the main 3 is just way too off to be convinving...

[–] NidDAlouette 11 years ago

Well, since Reed Fish was the one to cast "Alexis Bledel" and "Schuyler Fisk" in his telling of what happened, I suppose the bigger question is whether the townspeople of Muddy Meadows found it to be believable, as neither of those two actresses were the ladies he was actually involved with in his real life.