MovieChat Forums > Haunting Sarah (2005) Discussion > heather/ erica relationship

heather/ erica relationship


What about their rivalry? At the beginning when they were little girls, didn't one of them practically let the other (blindfolded) walk out into traffic? And wasn't heather jealous that she couldn't conceive when erica learned she was pregnant?

reply

I thought in the beginning they were working on their "twin talking" where they seem to be able to tell what the other one is thinking or feeling. I mean at the end of that piece the blindfolded girl turns to the other one and says "I heard you" or something like that. I just figured the other one was telling her not to go.

As for the jealousy thing, I think she was just upset cause her sister was pregnant and she had problems conceiving. (I watched it the day it came out and not again since so I don't remember who was who, I just really remember the basis of the movie.)

Better to be without anyone, then to be with someone other then your true love.

reply

heather could conceive.. if you look closely at the end of the movie, she is pregnant.

reply

Now see, if I was Erica, I would have cut Heather out of my life when I found out that she was using my daughter to bring back her crazy dead son.

reply

Like the lady in the movie, Rosie, said, David didn't realize that he was no longer living; so I think he is not to be blamed, although I did recoil a bit when he called Erica a "(You're not my mother! Get away from me,)bitch!"

But yes, it does have great potential, but the plot was only mediocre at best and the whole filming is slaughtered by the producer or director's lack of insistence for perfection; be it horror-wise or the more emotional part of the film.

I did think the boy's performance was exceptional though!!

This movie is worth-watching, but it doesn't have that gripping effect on its viewers, as anyone would expect from a horror movie.
Six and a half stars at its best, I'd say.

reply

i thought about half way that they were gonna pull the "evil twin" card! coz it seriously looked that way to me...what with all erica "twin studies" so i thought david was like the devil spawn!! :O haha it was seriously only until the very end (the hospital i think) that i realized "ohh so heather is NOT the evil twin"
O.o
good movie though! surprisingly! just a confusing ending!

reply