MovieChat Forums > Unidentified (2006) Discussion > Why did God give him bad cellphone recep...

Why did God give him bad cellphone reception?


Why did God give him Bad Cell Phone reception?
(And other things that made no sense about this movie)

1: I think this is the elephant in the room, the fake Rapture which some how proves a point...? So let me just get this straight, every one in the office, had nothing better to do than to put on this little performance, with quite a bit of enthusiasm. There wasn't on guy, not even an intern, who was like: "Wait, what are we doing?" And that girl pretending that her neice just disappeared and acting all frantic and then: Surprise!!! Everything's fine. Proof positive that Christians are creepy. And doesn't this whole excersise go to show that how people can get worked up in a frenzy and believe in something that isn't true...like say...the rapture?

2: These so called UFO sightings...okay...was it God trying to reach lost souls? Or was it the devil trying to get people to think that UFOs are real so we will believe that we are not alone in this vast universe? I watched the movie, seriously. And I have no idea what this was about. What was with the smell of sulfar? That would mean it was the devil's work, okay fine, but why when they were confronting that mechanic in his living room did they say that God was trying to reach out to him. Which brings me to number 3.

3: First of all, my mother is a Pagan and she is not evil. You're an idiot.
Secondly, there wasn't single likeable character in this movie. I blame the direction because you could have added depth to some of the characters rather than have this melodramtic crock of "Good guys" and "Bad guys". It was assinying how judgemental the "Spiritual Guru" was. Telling his buddy to "Get Serious". It's just...so...out of line. Intrusive, bullying, ignorant...whatever.

4: This secret Goverment group/guy that stages UFO encounters, believes that UFO encounters are an act of God or whatever (still not clear on that), and reach out to reporters. Wow... okay...wow. And what did he acutally tell them that they didn't already "know" you'd think he'd have some kind of evidence, documents maybe, scripture, whatever.

I seriously just can't keep writing about this movie.

Bottom line, it stunk.

And there's plenty more about it that didn't make sense, like all of the incoherent rhetoric that was supposed to pass as serious wisdom...well, whatever.

reply

First of all, to be completely honest I am a full Bible believing Christian. Secondly, I agree with almost every point Josiah23 made.
What in the world was with the whole fake rapture in the end? This practical joke was foolishly mean and showed a gross sign of immaturity. If this act was typical of all Christian persuasion, it would be absolutely shameful. "Proof positive that Christians are creepy"-- Yeaaa, this had a definite creep-out factor to it. I do not think that a practical joke about going to hell would be in any circumstance an appropriate way to minister to someone, much less convey God's love which is the ultimate goal of believers.
I would appreciate it if someone who was involved with this movie or someone who knows more about it than I do would please explain why this scene is in the movie or maybe what in the world people were thinking to even conceive such an idea much less put it on video?
There was a certain lack of explanation about the UFO sightings other than the so-called "guru's" intense, almost hateful rantings about demonic activity (which certainly could have been explained better or touched on more). Josiah23 I think they meant that the people involved with these sightings had had demonic encounters dressed up as alien abductions. All the talk about how God was reaching out to the man was basically a confusing throwback to how God is always reaching out to everyone, most of all unbelievers. I support the belief that there are demons and that they will harm those that are not protected, but I do not encourage the particular emphasis on and demonization of Wiccans or any specific group of unbelievers and think that they should not have targeted only the people with "ties to the occult" (as the Guru says). Are the movie creators suggesting that everyone who have had "encounters" with aliens are Wiccans or Pagans? Because the "guru" made sure to point out that all these people practiced occult? The suggestion that a Wiccan wife is the sole cause of a poor man's alien hallcinations?? I am not pretending that I would ever dabble in Wiccan or Pagan affairs; however, such vast and hasty generalizations made on these "supernatural" occurances soon become a little nauseating. These are the same kinds of assumptions that have fueled hatred and corruption throughout Christian history.
The characters were two-dimensional and rude. ALL of them seemed unpolished like small children trying to verbally attack each other into believing the others' side. Rebecca St.James' character was sweet but still a little flat. As a writer, I found them appalling. As a Christian, they were disheartening. The premise of this movie was decent but it seems so halfway pulled together. The requisites of Christianity is something that will rightfully step on toes, but this movie drunkenly danced on and crushed toes.

If one makes a movie to share the gospel and finds this calling of any importance,
than one should have enough fear and respect of God to consider every single painstaking detail and the reactions that your storyline will invoke.

If the makers of this movie had done this than they would have permeated the storyline with logic and mystery that could only be pulled back to God and left the evangelical rants to more charismatic preachers. The visual and thought-provoking medium of film is clearly used improperly when the characters must exhaustively continue to present Christ's message and its relevance to the plot. For goodness sake, use some subtlety. Do not take away man's GOD-GIVEN freewill by shoving the message of God's love down people's throats because that absolutely denounces the entire premise of Jesus's death which was to provide a way for those with freewill to CHOOSE on their own to be with God (not that we can't encourage them, but this was too forced). I thank the makers for their intention but this was such a miss.. I would only use it in my Sunday school class to show the kids how they SHOULDN'T be a "guru".

Try harder next time.

reply

tonisfaith, extend your logic. Consideration of "...every single painstaking detail..." would call into question the validity of Christ and Christianity. There is a reason we get Christian movies like "Unidentified".


reply