Season 1: The Pineapple Incident
Season 2: Slap Bet
Season 3: Spoiler Alert
Season 4: The Best Burger in New York
Season 5: The Playbook
Season 6: Bad News
Season 7: The Best Man
Season 8: The Final Page
Season 9: How Your Mother Met Me
Bump
shareBump
shareI would have to look at each season but the most memorable scene and therefore episode is the "Nothing Suits Me Like A Suit" Broadway style number.
shareSeason 1: The Limo - This episode is one that I watch every New Years Eve or New Years day. So many NYE's in my 20's and early 30's come flooding back when I watch it.
Season 2: Ted Mosby Architect
Season 3: The Bracket - "I WAS there... trust me... it's fake baby!
Season 4: 3 Days of Snow (really hard season for me to pick a favorite, with time becoming one of my favorite seasons of the show)
Season 5: Jenkins over the years has jumped the spot from Slapsgiving 2
Season 6: Blitzgiving
Season 7: Tailgate
Season 8: Time Travelers
Season 9: How Your Mother Met Me, but Rally has my favorite "the Mother" scene
I love Best Burger in New York, but it is so hard to watch if I haven't already had a meal. Season 8 is one of my highest scored seasons on a per episode basis, and yet I really don't have a feel for the season in my memory. I tossed up Time Travelers.
season 1: 1x22 "Come On" and 1x18 "Nothing Good Happens After 2 A.M."
season 2: 2x02 "The Scorpion and The Toad",2x05 "World's Greatest Couple",2x06 "Aldrin Justice" and 2x14 "Monday Night Football"
season 3: 3x16 "Sandcastles in the sand"
season 4: 4x24 "The Leap"
season 5: 5x08 "The Playbook"
season 6: 6x14 "Last Words"
season 7: 7x03 "Ducky Tie"
season 8: 8x01 "Farhampton" and 8x20 "The Time Travelers"
season 9: 9x14 "Slapsgiving 3: Slappointment in Slapmarra"