Someone explain this


*SPOILERS*


So the kids (actors) in season 1 would have been around 17 -19 years old.

By season 9 they would be in their 20's and are 27 (son) and 29 (daughter)as of 2016.
So with the ending being so dumbly Ted trying to get the kids approvsl to ask out Robin and they have a scene where te kids are talking to Ted and tellig him they are ok with it.
Have they planned that from the first season ? Because the kids would have been in their mid 20's in 2013 and look completely different.
Also Teds voice for 9 seasons telling the story was Bob Saget so why when it cuts to Josh's ted telling the kids "thats how i met your mother" , why use the bob saget voice for 9 years ?

reply

Yes they obviously filmed the ending scene with the kids years ahead of time, so yes the ending was planned as is all along. I don't know exactly what year they filmed it (I think during S2?) so that the kids would appear to be the same age.

reply

Yes, as the other poster said, and as the writers talk about in the commentaries; it became quite obvious as they started filming season 2, that the actors playing the two kids were getting older. The son in particular had gotten notably taller between the start of season 1 and the start of season 2. This lead to the creators deciding to film a bunch of stock footage of the kids which they could use through the rest of the series, as well as their side of what they planned to be end of the show. This is why the kids stopped interacting with Future Ted after season 2; with the exception of "Last Cigarette," which they inexplicably used footage from the pilot for their reaction, even though they're wearing different clothes, and they had a similar reaction when Future Ted joked about meeting their mom when she was working as a stripper.
Now, the major problem here is the fact that they knew how the show was going to end, and did a piss poor job steering the show in that direction, but that's neither here nor there.

As for Ted's voice, it was predominantly a narrative device, to help viewers differentiate between present day Ted and the narrator; especially given how much the show bounced around in time through flashbacks and flash-forwards, this way we knew that when Ted sounded like Bob Saget, it was the furthest point in the story, in 2030.
It's also not that uncommon for people's voices to change over time, if albeit subtly. Whether or not they always planned to have Josh in that final scene, is not known. People have argued, not unreasonably, that the framing device of Future Ted's narrative is from such a point of view, that the voice we're hearing may be from Ted's perspective; how Ted hears his voice, which of course is different from how other people would hear his voice.


"Sorry, I mistook you for a corpse."

reply

It was Scott Bakula

reply

About the ending voice...

I understand your point. I think that the reason it wasn't Bob Saget's voice is because that part wasn't narrated anymore. We, the audience, finally got there, and is "actual" Ted, so to speak, the one who is telling that part.

reply