MovieChat Forums > In a Dark Place (2007) Discussion > What I Disliked About In A Dark Place (S...

What I Disliked About In A Dark Place (Spoilers)


They need to send this film back to the dark place where they found it. I have not read The Turn of the Screw, which is the 1898 novella written by Henry James upon which this film is based. However, it appears that this novella sparked a great deal of debate regarding the intent of James in presenting a ghost story that might be more an extension of normal experience than super-natural forces.

Edmund Wilson was an American writer and literary critic who was only three years old when this book was written. Wilson was the first known person to support the theory that Turn of the Screw was an examination of the Governess and her own insanity rather than a haunted house story. It appears that Wilson's interpretation of the book formed the basis for the screenplay, which left open some interpretation but tended to lean towards the insane governess point of view. I'm not certain how closely the screenplay followed the book or how much influence Wilson had on the finished product, but the film seemed to contradict itself at times, in an effort to leave open the possibilities.


For more:

http://flickrater.blogspot.com/2009/01/in-dark-place.html

reply

well put.

reply

I agree.

reply

Very well put indeed.

I was into the movie throughout the beginning... but getting towards the end... it just fell apart.


---------------------------------------
~~Lock The doors - Pretend You're Safe~~

reply

If you have not read the book I recommend it.

The books has so many levels. It is a ghost story but it also leaves things open to interpretation as to whether the nanny is crazy or not. It is also an examination of the way the children act that can be taken as they are just being kids and playing tricks on their nanny or possessed by spirits, good vs evil.

I read the book and it does not explain away anything. The ghosts are either real or a figment of an insane persons imagination or another way to take the book, is that everything is taken at face value - the ghosts are real AND the nanny is insane - not a good combination.

reply