MovieChat Forums > My Name Is Earl (2005) Discussion > Rate the seasons of MNiE (tl;dr - Season...

Rate the seasons of MNiE (tl;dr - Seasons 1+2 awesome / S3+4 crap)

posted 8 years ago by Philip_90
1 reply | jump to latest

Season 1 - 9/10
Season 2 - 8/10
Season 3 - 4/10
Season 4 - 5/10

The reason why I've rated Seasons 3 and 4 so low is due to the poor writing the episodes had, Earl didn't do his list and instead spent time doing either time in prison, chores for someone or in dream sequences. Plus, let's not forget Season 4 ended with a cliffhanger "To Be Continued".

And they never stated who's the father of Dodge and Earl Jr.

[–] punksummer 8 years ago

Season 1 10/10
Season 2 10/10
Season 3 9/10
Season 4 10/10

Yes I love this show that much. I don't get why people hate on the last season. You just can't hate cheerleader Randy and Joy with a big ass toe.