MovieChat Forums > X-Men Origins: Wolverine (2009) Discussion > Professor X walking at the end?

Professor X walking at the end?


How so? Or was he just a mental projection?

...then whoa, differences...

reply

Throughout the history of the comics, Prof. X has been able to walk at different times for different reasons.

reply

Would you care to speculate on the reason in this particular case?

These things can understandably be confusing for those of us not familiar with the details of the particular universe.

...then whoa, differences...

reply

I'd love to say something like Hank McCoy developed a formula which restored his ability to walk without suppressing his mental abilities, but I think they just fuqked with the story just for the sake of the movie.

reply

More than likely it was just a disregarded story point. They thought it would be a cool intro to have Professor X stand because it was a prequel so they could do something different like that.......I doubt they had any other reason for it.

I don't think anyone else paid much attention to this movie in regards to continuity afterwards. 'X-Men First Class' is a fantastic movie and actually had an awesome reason/story point for putting Xavier in a wheel chair.

reply

It was a mental projection. In DOFP Charles does the same thing in order to talk to Mistique

reply

That actually does make sense, thanks!

...then whoa, differences...

reply

[deleted]

K, that makes sense too. As much as anything else I guess.

...then whoa, differences...

reply

In DOFP Beast says that he designed the serum so Xavier could walk again, but he used too much of it because he wants to drown out the voices. It's therefore possible that he was using the same old serum, just at a more regulated dosage. We never saw him doing anything particularly spectacular in the flashback, so there's nothing to indicate that he was at full strength (as he would be if he was off that serum entirely or on a new one). He basically just detected that Jean was reading their minds. So it's possible that after 1973 he realized that he needed to scale back the dose and get back in the game, but he wasn't yet prepared to give up walking. A crisis that required him at optimal strength may have been the push he needed to realize that he couldn't have it both ways.

That could have happened before Origins (perhaps it was needing to help Jean that sparked his change of attitude) and he could have been projecting a mental image of himself to Scott... or not. If not that would explain why he was simply leading Scott to safety instead of shutting down everyone who was threatening them (note how he couldn't shut down Mystique when he was coming off the serum, but he could reach her).

reply

Great answer. I actually forgot Xavier was abusing the serum.

Regulating the proper dose, one could say he absolutely COULD walk and use his power.

reply

[deleted]

Where did you get the end of Origins was 81? The 3 mile island meltdown was 79.

In the kingdom of the blind, you're the village idiot.

reply

When they were promoting DOFP the studio put out a timeline that confirmed that Origins took place in the 80s. Some people claimed this was a retcon, but there were those of us who were arguing that was a possibility since 2009. The movie never said that the film's climax was supposed to represent what "really happened" during the Three Mile Island incident; that is something people assumed. The thing though is that it doesn't make sense. Why would they build a whole fake power plant to hide a base and how would they even pull that off since it would be obvious that it is not contributing to the power grid? Thus, the more likely scenario is that Stryker simply moved in after the meltdown because, as he said in the film, people's fears of radiation would keep them away (it was safe to go there after the meltdown but the general public feared otherwise).

If you're among those now thinking about the collapse of the cooling tower, I would remind you that neither cooling tower collapsed during the meltdown and they are still standing today. They are also highly visible from far off so there is no way that one could collapse and then secretly be rebuilt without someone noticing, (either during or after the incident) and therefore it's an event that is unique to the X-men universe.

As for Supperhero's exact year of 1981; that's based on his own calculations. In short, he figures that Origin's teenage Cyclops couldn't be older than Apocalypse's teenage Cyclops so if Origins took place in the 80s, before 1983, then... you get the idea.

reply

As for Supperhero's exact year of 1981; that's based on his own calculations. In short, he figures that Origin's teenage Cyclops couldn't be older than Apocalypse's teenage Cyclops so if Origins took place in the 80s, before 1983, then... you get the idea.


Nicely put, that's my logic.

(I'm Supperhero LOL)

reply

Because Professor X has always been able to walk, he is just a lazy *beep* who prefers to use a wheelchair.

reply