Spanish Bishop Slams Film


From www.catholicnewsagency.com -

Spanish bishop slams new film on St. Teresa of Avila

Madrid, January 04, 2006 (CNA) - Bishop Demetrio Fernandez of Tarazona, Spain, has issued a letter denouncing a new film on St. Teresa of Avila that portrays her as a sex symbol and is the subject of an “orchestrated media campaign” to depict the saint solely “through the prism of sex.”

Teresa, Muerte y Vida (Teresa, Death and Life) is currently being shot in Spain by director Ray Loriga and stars Paz Vega as St. Teresa.

In his letter entitled, “Poor St. Teresa,” Bishop Fernandez noted the human and spiritual transcendence of the Spanish mystic who “made history before the arrival of the feminist movement,” and he lamented the media attention being given to “the filming of a movie that presents the saint as ‘morbidly sexy’.”

“The curious thing is that the people behind these absurd ideas tend to accuse the Church of being obsessed with sex, and it turns out they are the ones who see sex everywhere, they see sex even where there is none,” Bishop Fernandez maintained.

Such individuals “are unable to grasp kindness and goodness, and instead project their own filth onto persons, realities and subjects which have nothing to do with what they are putting forward,” he continued. “They remain stuck in a sort of Freudianism—Freud himself has surpassed even his greatest followers.”

Bishop Fernandez noted that “mystical experiences are not neurotic experiences and they have nothing to do with sexual repression.” Only through faith can one truly understand such experiences, he noted. “A person who doesn’t have faith shouldn’t get involved with this subject matter because he or she will ruin it, and on top of everything else the person thinks he or she is creating a work of art,” the bishop added.

Spanish newspapers reported the film to be a portrayal of St. Teresa as a feminist sexual revolutionary who described her mystical experiences as “carnal orgasms.” Bishop Fernandez responded by calling for respect for the saint.

“Respect for the truth as she explained it her life. Respect to not damage under any pretext what are sublime experiences of God and the sacred. Poor St. Teresa, or better yet, poor men and women who don’t know how to see anything but sex in these mystical experiences,” Bishop Fernandez stated.

He hoped that those involved in making a film about the saint would be “led to understand deeper realities that have nothing to do with sex.”
+ + + + + + + + +
If you've read this far, I would say that the Discalced Carmelite Order, which Nuestra Santa Madre Teresa founded, will be none too happy with the release of this film.

FWIW,
Dvora, O.C.D.S.

reply

"A person who doesn’t have faith shouldn’t get involved with this subject matter because he or she will ruin it, and on top of everything else the person thinks he or she is creating a work of art,” the bishop added."

IMO, he can't really say that until he has seen the subject matter in question. Even if he doesn't like the notion of mystical experiences being interpreted as expressions of sexual repression, he can't declare that such an interpretation is automatically invalid and therefore not a work of art. It may very well be art. Bernini's sculpture of St Teresa is very sensual in its conception of her mystical experience, for instance - so such an interpretation doesn't disqualify a work from being artistic (even if the Church doesn't consider it historically accurate)

reply

The Catholic church doesn't approve it? Good, it may be a decent movie, then.

reply

It's clear to me that you dont know anything about the Movies the Church "approves". You'll be surprised.
What do you call a "decent movie" by the way?

Q: What happens if you get a gigabyte? A: It Megahertz!

reply

This is all a lie. The Spanish Bishops Conference have said nothing about this movie.

reply

I agree with Fmartiterron. Doesn't the church see that the more they disapprove of a film, the more people will want to see it? I would probably not have seen this one, but if it bothers the church, I hope it is watched a lot, and I'm going to help for it to happen, just because the church doesn't want people to see it.

reply

The Church also disapproves alcoholism... so, why don't you drink like a fish, turn yourself an alcoholic and die? The Church would be "very upset".

Q: What happens if you get a gigabyte? A: It Megahertz!

reply

Well, I don't need to go to church, to take care of my health. A doctor does the trick, and at least, he doesn't care about what happens on his patients' beds. Besides, if a doctor advises you not to drink too much, it's because of your liver, and eventually because of your health and life. But if the Church takes care of your liver, it's only because they claim they are worried about something only they seem to see, and that they call "eternal life".

BTW, a little concern for people's health (even if it WERE for the right reasons) doesn't pay for two thousand years of manipulation. Even the worst monsters of humanity have had their nice side, and that didn't account for their atrocities. Or will anyone defend Hitler, just because he liked dogs?

reply

Who cares about what those former friends of Franco have to say?

As somebody else mentioned, if the church slams this movie, it has to be an interesting film. In fact it is. Flawed but interesting.

reply