MovieChat Forums > The Hunting Party (2007) Discussion > What really offended me about this movie...

What really offended me about this movie was... (spoiler)


How two aging frat boys and a bafoon just show up and catch a war criminal in a few days, seemingly only because they're Americans who really really care.

There's something suspicious about how whole nations haven't been able to do this, I'll give them that.

BUT... if these 3 civillians can do it so easily because they're driven by a personal vendetta, then wouldn't some of the hundreds of thousands of natives do it too? Wouldn't someone who's had their entire family killed off have just as much (or probably more) reason to find him? And succeed, since it's apparently so easy?

I feel this insults those of us who've been through this war because according to Hunting Party we must either A) not be as smart as these three Americans, or B) we must not care as much.

reply

or C) not able to get anywhere near him because you would be shot, as they (albeit in the movie) would have been if Hunt had not been recognised. Locals, or natives if you like, protect the wanted men.

The people who *want* to catch the war criminals are not locals, they may be in the same country but they're not living in the communities where these criminals are hiding. And entering those communities, attempting to approach these men, would be endangering their lives just as much as the three Americans endangered their own lives.

The film doesn't set out to prove that three buffonish Americans can find a war criminal because the Bosnians are not very smart, it sets out to prove that the west is not interested in capturing these people. As the original article did.

The ending, where they do capture him (with the help of a "native") is pure fantasy but necessary to bring dramatic resolution to the film. It says nothing about the people of Bosnia.

reply

It was a MOVIE...not the Discovery Channel......and like most movies someone will always be offended.....Get over it Miles...geez...or perhaps grow-up!

reply

>It was a MOVIE...not the Discovery Channel......and like most movies someone will always be offended.....Get over it Miles...geez...or perhaps grow-up!

I think you mean, "Get over it *gummybugmua*." Miles wasn't offended. He was simply trying to explain to gummybugmua his take on the nature of the film.

reply

You're correct.....my mistake. Miles, my apology! and "get over it gummybugmua"

reply

lol..

Gentlemen. You can't fight in here. This is the War Room.

reply

That's better, lol:)

reply

TBF they didnt really find him... He found them at first and they would of been killed if... well you know

reply

There are quite a few mistakes. First, in the first scene of the movie the song is Arabic and has nothing to do with the movie at all, nor with Bosnia, you'd never hear that music there, ever. There were some good Bosnian rock songs in the rest of the movie, which was cool.

Other things that would not have happened in the real world:
- Gere would have gotten shot the same day when his girlfriend did;
- Three of them would have gotten killed if not by 'Karadzic/Mladic' in that hut, then by the CIA after they had been found;
- They could never have caught him like they did at the end, that's more than just fiction, it's stupid;
- The criminal of that calibre would not try to run after he had been left in the middle of that town at the end, he would have stood tall and either take a bullet to the head or maybe the people of that town would decide to sell him to the UN for 5 million dollars:
- Boghdanovic has no 'h', it should have been Bogdanovic;

reply

@ joemoe66

100% correct, i just hated how *beep* false and preopaganda this gay movie was.
jesus christ, even star wars was more realistic then this *beep* excusse for a movie!!!

reply

[deleted]

"Your just a stupid serbian sympathizer, its about time they make a movie which really depicts those animals (the serbs) "

oh the irony of that line... shees

reply

[deleted]


U little serb loser...

USA as usual, did a great job in Kosovo Republic...

Greetings to NATO

reply

uhmm.. No.
Serbs had their point of view, so did the bosnians, both had flaws.. both made really big mistakes.
But this movie isn't about them.. it's about the inability of the UN, NATO and any peacekeeping corp in the former Yugoslavia, to do anything about catching the people that deserved to be dead in the first place, instead of those approximately 100.000 dead people on both sides. And it pretty damn well delivers.

reply

I agree . It was sranje !!

reply

in the first scene of the movie the song is Arabic and has nothing to do with the movie at all, nor with Bosnia, you'd never hear that music there, ever. There were some good Bosnian rock songs in the rest of the movie, which was cool.
Barra Barra rocked ten times better than any other song in the movie, so what if the singer was algerian rather than Bosnian? They played the same song in Black Hawk Down too, and that was in Somalia not Algeria either.

Other things that would not have happened in the real world
And if the movie was a documentary instead of satire you would have a point.

reply

I agree. I loved this film. And that's all it was. A film.

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/justine-waddell/









reply

And what sadly amuses me is the number of people from all over the world who will, in a few years, after watching this movie, strongly believe that it was "based on a true story" and made by the actual events... History is sooo old - fashioned, anyway, there's Hollywood to be our teacher... :-(

reply

The thing was that girl had connections that basically gave the inside scoop on Fox's habits and whatnot. it's kinda like when that Nazi generial tried to assassinate Hitler when he took those personal strolls in the morning.

reply

The man they caught was just one of the Fox's body doubles, thats why he freaked out when left in the village.

reply

The only criminal of war that Americans should be allowed to find and kill should be George Bush. The rest of the criminals of war pale in front of him.

reply

The movie was implying that America bribed him to get him to step down and end the bloodshed, because they said if he stepped down then we would not arrest him. Something along the same lines with the UN. And, Richard Grere's character probably DOES care more than anyone else, because his wife and unborn child were murdered by the Fox. Stop looking for reasons to hate this movie and pay more attention to it and everyone's motives.

reply

How many wars have you lived through?

How many nights have you spent in cellars or air-raid shelters (if you were lucky to reach it)? How many times have you been in a train driving through an open field, watching planes flying over you asking if this train is a target? How many times did you send your kids to school knowing that a bomb from a sudden plane, a garnet from nearby village, a sharpshooter's bullet from across the street could appear and you'll never see them alive again? How many friends did you lose in the war and how many refugees did you give a hand?

There have been made great war comedies probably about every war in the history. This war isn't an exception. When a comedy is made by people who know what they are talking about, it can be funny, even if it is made by those that have been on the enemy side. But when someone belonging to a nation which has made nothing good to stop the war, in fact both in active and passive way made it last longer, be more cruel, end with injustice (and, last but not least, started more wars during last few decades than all other nations together - but this is not the topic here) makes a movie that shows local people inferior and incapable solving their own problems (yes, they could have solved it long ago if those same "civilized" nations didn't declare embargo on weapons for attacked countries) - yes, people in these countries have all moral right to feel insulted.

Or, simplified, you accept the usual Hollywood concept, that Gere's wife and child are, as Americans, by far superior to Bosnian people, so it is normal that Bosnians don't care for their worthless families, leaving him as the only emotional human person with family feelings that are unknown to those wild tribes.

reply

Yes Im sure many local civilians who have lost friends and family went on there own hunt to find (the Fox) an other war criminals.
But if you noticed the charaters in the movies where nearly be-headed. Im sure that WASN'T the first timee they used that butchers shed. The guy with the tattooed head seemed like he'd done it before.

Dont forget earlyer when they met up with the three orange cars at the bottom of the hill and almost had their brains blown out. Only the fact that they knew one of them is what saved them

So agin yes im sure many people have come as close to meet with the Fox, just few live to tell about it or succseed in killing him.

reply

This is a movie inspired by actual events, not the 6 o'clock news. If you're going to quibble over "why is there arabic music playing" you need to expand your horizons... or did you not notice the ring tone that saved the 3 Americans??? The movie was trying to get you to think about who really runs things in this world, and who appears to run things. One of the age old lessons the CIA learned from the British Empire was to leave the bad guy in charge, if he could be controlled. At least the bad guy you know is one you know... as opposed to one you could get! World policy which stands to this day.

reply

The movie is indeed inspired by actual events. Five journalists went and came close to finding Karadciz within 72 hours.

They were also mistaken for CIA assassins and even met the real CIA who were trilled that the journalists came so close. One of the journalist stated that he tought the CIA was willing to arrest karadciz but that the UN wanted it to fail for all kind of reasons. He didn't buy the fact that a bunch of journalists could come so close and other organizations with millions to spend couldn't. In the movie it was the Americans that got the blame but the actual events didn't support that according to the journalist. He tought the movie gave a decent depiction of the actual events but a bit romanticized and over the top, but he guessed that it was common to Hollywood movies.

reply

All i want to say if it was that easy catching war criminals there would be peace on the world.
They have to stop makin movies like that who watched "Behind enemy lines" knows what am i talking about.
It's just stupid unrealistic movie which affends balkan people.

reply

All i want to say if it was that easy catching war criminals there would be peace on the world.
They have to stop makin movies like that who watched "Behind enemy lines" knows what am i talking about.
It's just stupid unrealistic movie which affends balkan people.

The problem is that war criminals tend to have a lot of friends. What was probably the reason that they could move around freely is political games. Arrested those "war criminals", which are usually seen as heroes by their own people, would probably result to renewed fighting. The UN probably wanted peace and didn't really care that much about the criminals or the buried bodies.

reply

Ok I got to say this? I didn't watch it to learn how to catch a war criminal, I watched it for entertainment value, and on that end? It did what it was supposed to. Entertain me. I just don't believe the people who made it were making a "Schindlers List" they were making a entertaining movie "based" on fact'

In a thousand years, there will be no men and women, just wankers, and that's fine by me.

reply

Okey guys, I dont think that they wanted to offend any of the people, I think they were referring to UN and all the great countries for not wanting to capture him.. And by the way I dont think that anyone down there would want to find him because people get killed for such ideas.
The point of the movie probably was that USA UN and other great unions deliberately attempts to cover up that they´re negotiating with the enemy and that they´re trying their best but "cant find" the war criminals.
Its just like the whole 9/11 thing with Bin Laden

reply

I watched this movie and went out to catch a war criminal of my own. I set out on the 8th of May, wish my luck!

reply

I just saw the movie, and I have to say that I thought it was pretty good. I don't think, and I didn't feel that the movie was trying to demonize the Serbs in general, like some people said. Beside some liberties that the script took with the actual facts, I think it still stands out as an entertaining AND thoughtful film. Not only is this movie trying to make a point about the questionnable efforts put in place by the international autorities in the capture of war criminals, I think it also does make a good point about what the reality of journalism might be, and the fact that what we actually see on the news is often not the whole truth.

Bill Foster: I'm the bad guy?...How did that happen?

reply

Then why didn't they?

reply

Step one: realize the movie is a total satire and not to be taken seriously.

Step two: watch it again in this new light.

reply

step three: this movie sucks ass

reply