english version???


hello

i read somehere there is an english dubbed version of this movie. anyone knows sth about it???

reply

Why would anybody want an English version?

Considering so much of this movie is sung, an English-language version would be a really stupid idea, unless they got some really good singers AND rewrote the songs in English

reply

Yeah, that is true. I don't think such a version exists, but if you won't be able to understand it I suggest subtitles? ^^;

I found them distracting, but without them I wouldn't have been able to understand the film :( Didn't stop the film from being wonderful, though!

reply

I can kind of understand the logic, since it would be a bit overwhelming to process the visuals, the text, and the audio all at the same time. In my case I had trouble caused since I could actually understand some chunks of the Mandarin but that was just a distraction since it wasn't enough to entirely forgo subtitles.

That said, I was impressed that the English translated subs also managed to rhyme for the most part.

reply

Still, that wouldn't be so bad/hard, I mean, they've translated songs into other languages for other musicals (ummm...ok, disney : D). My guess is that maybe there wouldn't be enough of a market for it in English? I don't know though, I have yet to see the movie. I'll try to watch it in Mandarin but I only know a few words so I'll probably have to rely on subtitles :(

reply

Alot of people say that this is a rip off of Moulin Rouge but it isn't. I would suggest Subtitles also. Even if you understand chinese it's probably smart if you read them

reply

I would think that it would just be common sense that if you want to watch a movie in a language you don't understand, use the subtitles.

reply

The DVD and Blu-ray have a halfway decent English dub, and the songs are left in Mandarin. So you can choose dialogue in English and the songs remain the same as in the straight Chinese film.

However I agree the total English subs are the way to go for the purist.

reply