MovieChat Forums > Walkout (2006) Discussion > Ethnicity + Equality

Ethnicity + Equality


Okay, first of all, i don't care what ethnicity Alexa Vega is... Wouldn't it have made more sense and had a greater impact, if she would have been perhaps, dare I say, more stereotypically Chicana?! I am Mexican, and damn proud of it, but please, all I could think was, why is some little white girl playing the lead?

Second, for those of you who think they should have gone back to their own country if they weren't being treated well, why don't you guys do the same? Unless you are full-blooded Native American, you aren't originally from this country either. Is it wrong to protest for equal rights when we ARE in fact Equal?



How can we be expected to teach children to learn how to read if they can't even fit in the building?

reply

[deleted]

saveferris22; Preach it...I agree with you.

"Es la ignorancia de ellos y de no saber y tampoco de investigar sobre nuestra patria."

This post elaborates about ethnicities/cultures/languages & etc within Mexico.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0452703/board/thread/39421680


reply

No, like i said, i am mexican. and my mom looks as white as anyone. Do you really think that i would say that she shouldnt be considered hispanic? No, what i'm saying is that people Stereotypically consider hispanics to look a certain way. Would they take it seriously if they thought some little white girl was playing the lead? i mean, i live in the Midwest, i know how people that dont live in place that has a strong hispanic influence think. Look, i love the movie, its extremely moving. If you did like it, you guys should see "The Children's March". However, just because our culture, everyones culture SHOULD evolve, doesnt mean it is, or will be anytime soon, so to make a point, we do what we can.

And i only put the other comment on there because i've seen it. And just because they have lived here for generations does not mean they speak perfect english and have not had to face a comment such as that. I lived in Texas, i knew people who'd lived there for generations and couldnt speak a word of english. And, i am happy. however, i live in iowa, i am one of 6 hispanics at my school, what diversity do i face?

How can we be expected to teach children to learn how to read if they can't even fit in the building?

reply

I am not hispanic but the girl playing Paula Crisostomo looked hispanic to me. Although it seems silly to me to wory about how "Mexican" the girl looked it wasn't even a factor to me while watching the movie. Plus isn't the real Paula half Filipino?

reply

A lot of mestizo's LOOK white!!

Who would you want to play the lead role? A women from Chiapas?

Not all mestizos look like that by a long shot.Besides, Alexa Vega is better for that part than Jennifer Lopez ( a black mullatto). Wouldn't you agree?

reply

[deleted]

"Second, for those of you who think they should have gone back to their own country if they weren't being treated well, why don't you guys do the same? Unless you are full-blooded Native American, you aren't originally from this country either. Is it wrong to protest for equal rights when we ARE in fact Equal? "

Because most people's ancestors immigrated here legally.

reply

"Because most people's ancestors immigrated here legally."

Haha that's what you think! The truth is, before the Immigration Act of 1924, there were no immigration laws to break (unless you had the misfortune of falling under the Chinese Exclusion Act). And "most people's ancestors", as you say, immigrated before that time. They came by the millions during the two greatest waves of immigration this country has ever had. And even after 1924, many Europeans continued to immigrate illegally. These illegals included people of Irish, Italian, Polish, Jewish and German ethnicity, the same people whose descendants consider themselves fully American today, to the point which they feel perfectly justified condemning illegal immigration. My point is, very few of our ancestors had to wait for a visa before coming here. Keep that in mind when discussing illegal immigration.

reply

Preach.. but Alexa Vega may not be full blooded, she's Columbian and White.. and from what I know she's proud that she's part ''latina'' if u will, I think it was a good choice for her to play Paula, she did a good job, i dont know about you but i dont know many mixed latinos that speak spanish good, or even at all.. in my opinion she was great even if she is part white, im a light skinned ''latina'' myself and i know how it goes.. she said it herself, it impacts a big part of the chicano/latino community and she's glad to be a part of it.. i dont think we should blame her for doing a good job in a film she was casted in.

reply

I didn't make an original post on this topic but wondered if it bothered other viewers. She is a good actress and has every right to play the part but making her over (tinting the color of her skin) took away something from the movie.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I just saw the movie...and I really think..it does not matter a bit if she is good or not for the role....she played the role very good...and in the end..what the whole movie is about matters. It's a powerful movie and iloved it.

"When life hands u lemons, just ask for some salt and tequilla!"

reply

isn't Alexa Vega like columbian?
i still think she did an awesome job playing a chicana
there aren't that many chicano actors unfortunately
but what i didn't like was her obviously fake tan
there were light chicanos back then too. they should've left her skin alone.

If i'd only known they were filming this movie, i could've been an extra. Our teacher told us after we watched the movie that we could've been extras. (i went to a mostly "hispanic" populated school)

reply