Question about the ending


I enjoyed this on the whole – the live nature of it went well, with relatively few slips (great recoveries by the actors) and a reused 1950s script that veered from charmingly dated to still profound after all these years. The central performances were great, even though Quatermass was so much younger than I would have expected, but there was some 'cheating' on the live thing in the form of lengthy prerecorded inserts of overhead cityscapes. Anyway, my question is: How did the now lost original last episode end? I have seen the film and I have read that the TV version had a monster manifested – with primitve special effects involving a rubber-glove puppet – on a model set of the interior of Westminster Abbey, as represented by a blow-up photo of the real thing (we laugh, but no doubt this looked very effective on the 9-inch TV screens of the time). Here, we had the Abbey substituted for Tate Modern, which was fine and allowed for the amusing if superflous addition of the art expert – but how hugely disappointing was the actual denouement? I was gutted! No rubber-glove beastie! No electrification of said monster as in the film! So, was that not in the TV series, then? Instead, Prof Q talked it to death by appealing to it (well, to the empty darkness as it was said to have somehow integrated itself into the walls and was not shown at all) and so drawing out the lingering humanity of the three human astronaut victims. Oh dear me! Was this not the oldest sci-fi cliché in the book even back in the 1950s? Even if not – and fair enough to Kneale if he invented this now well-worn idea – why were 2005 audiences denied a view of the final creature after all the build-up? Did something go wrong that necessitated the ending we got? I know it ran 20 minutes short on the schedule.

reply

Thats a good question about the ending, it was a bit flat. and i also spotted that it finished 20 minutes early. Maybe they did have something else planned but it just fell through? It was Live, the production people may have decided that they pushed it so far and they had to end it now before it became a big joke?

reply

I don't like being so cynical, but it was rather suspicious! I want to know, now. Anyone have the true story of what happened? Perhaps David Tenant can tell us in an interview when he becomes Doctor Who…?!

reply

The original scripts are available to view (on a PC!) if you have the BBC's [original] Quatermass Experiment DVD box set. It reveals that he does indeed "talk it to death" by appealing to the astronaut's remaining humanity. However the 'glove puppet creature' is largely plant at this stage, and when it commits suicide, Quatermass pulls off a mossy tendril with "a sound like a leaf tearing" and it dessicates and leaves begin to fall around him like snow. Sounds very visual and effective and not stupid and impossible like linking the scaffolding to the National Grid!

reply

No, the ending was transmitted & simultaneously recorded as per the dress rehearsal (also recorded, and used to fill in fluffs in the repeat). The final lines pretty much accord with the original 1953 script.

reply

Cheers for the information, people. I think the original show with its actual appearance of the creature, Quatermass pulling at a tendril and the falling leaves idea all make it sound a lot more effective than the recent reimagining with just a spotlight on the Prof and the 'ghosts' of the humans reappearing – funny how, half a century later, the director opted to be less ambitious with the same script!

I am prepared to accept that Kneale's 'talk the mutation to death by appealing to humanity's dregs within it' solution was marvellous in the 50s. I think it would have worked today if handled a bit better visually, as I say above. Unfortunately, as a plot solution, it can now seem hackneyed, having been ripped off in a great many sci-fi feature films and episodes of things such as Star Trek and Doctor Who (see below). Still, as you say, wiring in the electricity supply is no more satisfactory a dramatic conclusion (and similarly well-used), if more visually spectacular.

Examples of the original(?) Quatermass appeal-to-submerged-humanity solution being reused elsewhere in Sci-Fi:
The Twilight Zone (at least one episode I can think of)
Doomwatch (film – and series?)
Star Trek (series) – numerous eps, I seem to remember (and all the subsequent series?)
Star Trek: The Motion Picture
Return of the Jedi
The Fly (remake)
Hellraiser III
Event Horizon
Doctor Who – Spearhead from Space, The Ark in Space, Four to Doomsday, Resurrection of the Daleks, Revelation of the Daleks, The Trial of a Time Lord, Dalek, The Long Game, The Empty Child… and counting!
Can anyone else think of any more?

reply

Also similar is the attempt at confusing a super computer by giving it a puzzle that supposedly defies logic...as if a super computer capable of artificial intelligence would have a total melt down if you recite a confusing riddle. Well apparently it works in various episodes of Doctor Who and Star Trek.

Well as for the appeal to humanity, maybe the next time I get sick with a virus I'll try to appeal to its conscience and hope that it mysteriously dies.

reply

I think that the ending with a giant creature atop St Paul's Cathedral was in the movie version made by Hammer in 1955. I never saw the original TV series (I was too young - honestly!) but I did see the sequel "Quatermass 2" although I was only 6 or 7 at the time - it cetrainly gave me nightmares!

reply

no they just had got it down so neatly that the bbc had allocated too much time for it not that the cut it off too soon

reply

[deleted]