MovieChat Forums > 100 Greatest Cartoons (2005) Discussion > Simpsons does not deserve no. 1 spot

Simpsons does not deserve no. 1 spot


no doubt simpsons was once a partially funny show when i was a kid...but it just kept getting and the jokes more stupid

no.1 spot should go to a show that has continued on a huge impact and quality thoughout the years...ie south park






"Im not just sure Butters, Im HIV positive"

reply

1. "The Simpsons" has been on the air over 20 years. Even at its worst, it is still better than much of what is on television.

2. You speak of "impact" ... "South Park" would never have aired if not for "The Simpsons" coming along first.

3. "The Simpsons" started as a cult show, but today it is a legitimate phenomenon being appreciated across age groups, geography, etc. "South Park" remains very cultish and very much unchanged.

4. As time went on, "The Simpsons", in a sense changed the country. What was once unacceptable, became accepted. "The Simpsons" won over an audience. As I said, "South Park" remains out on the fringe, and is not anywhere near as influential (on society and on animation) as "The Simpsons".

reply