Better than the book


To preface I'm a huge Maugham fan, but in this instance the film was substantially better than the book. In the past, although Maugham was a wonderful writer, the films adaption seemed to have missed the mark. I point specifically to " The Razor 's Edge " and " The Moon and The Sixpence" both true to the original, but failing to capture Maugham's unique essence. I,for one, particularly enjoyed "The Letter " one of Bette Davis' finest film but I for whose fidelity I can't vouch. In this case, the adaptation, was far better than the novel from which it was based. While the novel mainly focused on Kitty's maturation and growth as a woman and wife, here were given a broader canvas. In particular the film's exploration of the political climate of the times ,which was lacking in the novel, we are given some needed background material. While the novel seems to endlessly dwell on her infidelity with Charles, the film refuses to belabor it, while neatly dismissing it as somewhat trivial in the final scene.

reply

I also enjoyed the film over the book.

reply

I preferred the book.
(I like all Norton, Watt, and Schreiber in this movie)

reply

I love the movie and the book equally even though they are different. The book is almost completely about the workings of Kitty's mind and the transformation in her spirituality and the way she sees Walter. I found that to be priceless and fascinating and I wanted to keep reading it forever. But that kind of thing can be very hand to translate into film. So I really admire and love the way the movie increased the scope of the book. It provided a wonderful and cinematic way of bringing in more details about the political climate in the area and Walter's work on the typhoid epidemic and water crisis. By allowing Kitty to observe that and be more involved in it than she was in the book, the movie made her transformation very believable. Every time I see the movie (at least 5 times already) I admire more what it was able to accomplish. The book is a gem and definitely not a lesser work of art than the movie, but it doesn't give you the great, satisfying romantic reconciliation between Walter and Kitty that the movie provides.

reply