MovieChat Forums > Deal (2008) Discussion > All these poker movies...

All these poker movies...


not the good ones like Rounders, these second rate poker movie do the same thing. the main character pushes their chips in like a complete fish, they look at their cards like they've never player, they use play chips, etc. The detail sucks

reply

Not just that... they do not seem to show the table action well. That is my chief complaint. Half the time you have no idea what is going on in the hand and they are like one giant, vague montage. No strategy, no table images established... they should have the situations set up so we can develop our own opinion of the hands in play IMO... but we are never given enough information, often not even knowing what the main character has until he turns it over.

I think you could put suspense in a poker scene but they always focus on the dramatic angle and forget that the suspense of how the hands itself play out, apart from its ramifications on anything outside of the room, is what attracts us to these movies in the first place.

Rounders is a classic to me and the only poker movie I even like but even it was imperfect in this regard.

reply


I agree with regards no idea what is going on with the hands most of the time

I really enjoyed this film, DEAL, but that is/was a major gripe for me

Rounders is fantastic though

--------------------

" No Ace. Just You "

reply

"not the good ones like Rounders"

From a strictly poker perspective, Rounders is awful. It is entertaining, but the poker played in the movie is nothing short of terrible.

reply




Rounders is the Cadillac of poker films


--------------------

" No Ace. Just You "

reply