MovieChat Forums > The Burrowers (2008) Discussion > Mixing Westerns and Horror is an interes...

Mixing Westerns and Horror is an interesting mix


THE BURROWERS is an interesting eclectic mix of Westerns and monster horror. It's not the first to attempt this new sub-genre of horror, but right now I can only remember one other western horror flick, RAVENOUS (1999). I find the western horror sub-genre to be interesting. I'd like to see more.

ANACHRONISMS:

1) I'm ashamed that I didn't notice this inconsistency immediately. Another quick-witted imdb poster caught it right away. The screwball U.S. Army cavalry captain speaks with an oddball Southern accent but that's not it. The year is 1879, just 14 years after the Civil War. The southern people still retain a strong disdain of the U.S. Army federals. The imdb poster was right. There would be no southerners wearing the hated U.S. Army bluecoat uniform so soon after the Civil War. Southern patriotism would begin its resurrection with the Spanish-American War in 1898 and fully re-emerge with the U.S. involvement in the First World War in 1917.

2) LEVER-ACTION RIFLES. This has always been a favorite Hollywood anachronism. The U.S. Army purchased just a few thousand Henry, lever-action repeating rifles during the Civil War. But after the war, the U.S. Army turned its back on repeating rifles. There were hundreds of thousands of Springfield muzzle loaders in inventory that the post-war, cash-strapped U.S. Army was not going to scrap. The U.S. Army instead had their muzzle loading rifles converted to single-shot, breech loaders, called the Allin Trapdoor. The U.S. Army cavalry out in the west may have been lucky enough to carry surplus, 7-shot Spencer repeating carbines until those wore out. The rest had to be satisfied with allin trapdoor breech loading conversions of Springfield formerly muzzle loaders. The carbine version was especially popular with the cavalry. The rifle conversions went to the infantry.

3) Anybody watch the British cult classic horror flick from the 80s, called, XTRO? The alien monster in XTRO looks almost identical to the burrower creatures. The creatures resemble humanoid forms that look to be walking on their backs on all fours, crab-like.

reply

Well, I can come up with a plausible theory for a Southerner being a U.S. cavalry captain in 1879.
At the outset of the Civil War there were populations of Southerners who elected to remain loyal to the Union. Typically you would find these Southern Union loyalists in the border states of Maryland, Kentucky, Missouri, Kansas, and West Virginia (not technically a border state). That being the case, you might conceivably see post Civil War soldiers out in the far west who were border state Southerners, especially if these guys were just toddlers or kids at the end of the Civil War. (The term, 'Union' was dropped after the war, with the reunification of the nation)
One more comment. The post-Civil War United States suffered intermittent high unemployment for the next several decades. The United States Army was a logical choice of employment for able-bodied young men. The post-Civil War U.S. Army was a fraction of its former wartime self, about 28,000 men. The U.S. Army could afford to take a little more selective position with prospective recruits, given its tiny size and the large U.S. population available. But let's make this clear. Voluntary military service was not high on the list of the typical American's job choices. It's just like I wrote. Unemployment was high and the new U.S. Army was small, so everything balanced out.

reply

I think this genre (horror western) is an interesting idea but I didn't really like this movie. I found it kind of boring. And no, I don't have a particularly short attention span, it just didn't really grab me. I think it had potential with the storyline/unique genre but it didn't really live up to any of that.

Big Gay Al, it has recently come to our attention that you are gay.

reply

Dead Birds is another Western-horror film.

reply

this movie, ravenous, tremors 4, dead birds, and wyatt earp. these are the only movies mixing the western and horror genres right now that i can think of.

That's Leilei, my lifetime companda. I won her from David Bowie in a triva game.

reply

Good catches m8!

I also find the Horror / Western kind of entertaining (even the VERY Cheeeeeezy FULL MOON film 'OBLIVION' was a lot of fun) But, like apocalypse 24 above, I didn't really care for this film that much. Mostly because of the direction of the actors, I think. Although the actors themselves are quite good.

BTW...

'XTRO' Phuk'n ROX!!!

Cheers!







I have over 6000 films now, many of them very rare and OOP. I LOVE to trade. PLEASE ASK!

reply