MovieChat Forums > Tian bian yi duo yun (2005) Discussion > Chen Shiang-chyi and the Ending

Chen Shiang-chyi and the Ending


I have just rewatched The Wayward Cloud, and I am still not sure what exactly is going on in the film's final moments. Chen Shiang-chyi's arms slowly and limply fall to her sides--- certainly an unsettling scene, but are we to suppose that she has actually suffocated to death? Or should we take this simply as a sad image of complete surrender?

I have searched all over the internet to try to see whether anyone has said explicitly whether they think Chen Shiang-chyi suffocates to death or not, but just about no-one else, in their discussion of the ending, seems to have suggested that she dies. I wonder if this means that such a reading of the scene is a ridiculous and extravagant one. (In a way, I somewhat that is the case... to me at least, What Time Is It There? has unfortunately never felt quite the same since I considered the possibility that the character will go on to die in such a humiliating manner).

What do people on here think? Of course, it's quite possible that Tsai is being deliberately ambiguous here, but I wonder if this is one instance where we can rule out this one possibility (that is, the possibility of "death by suffocation").

reply

The sentiment at the end is one of wanting to be close to someone, and the troubles of being separate, it's one of the only times they really show their love for each other (although this is definitely not a simple love story!) I always think of her arms coming down as being almost like a physical sigh, the body so exhausted and depleted of water, exhausted from the warmth, the flies, the sweat.

reply

just saw the movie and this is what I think too. They finally consumate their love as it were. And she is released of all her tension for once (as she comes across as rather neurotic throughout the film). The tears being tears of joy.

Did you ever notice that people who believe in creationism look really un-evolved? - Bill Hicks

reply