MovieChat Forums > Keeping Mum (2006) Discussion > Obviously written by an american

Obviously written by an american


Typically british? It was but come on it was obviously written by an american. I knew this before I evem read it up. Lance was the guy lusted after by all the women and had a cool woooo! factor (even if he was a perve)? In what americans/brits film (written by an american) does this not happen? Lol it's funny when you think about it. How proud are american men?

I watched this film last night. I might buy it or rent it out. Great cast, ro, mag, pat.

reply

Actually one of the writers was American (Richard Russo) the other was British (Niall Johnson) who was also the director. I'm an American woman and I thought Lance was a prat and sleezy and icky - and about as appealing as battered grapes fried in cod liver oil. Which is to say EW!!!! Gross!

reply

"about as appealing as battered grapes fried in cod liver oil."

That's one of the funniest things I've ever read. Thank you!

reply

About as tasteful and truthful as a plumb job from Joe the Dumber!

Nothing is more beautiful than nothing.

reply

[deleted]

Oh god yes. We Americans can't help but remind the world of how sexy we are, and there is nothing that makes us women swoon more than a sleazeball in a tacky pimp shirt and a red g-string.... oh baby!

reply


I thought the exact opposite - Lance seems like a character written by a non-American looking to project their negative stereotypes of Americans onto him (i.e. sleazy, crass, tacky, horny, southern accent....).

Amen. And all that cal.

reply

Unlikly, Lance follows all the british stereotypes of the americans

and the bit about the flower arrangeing committee is so true, (if you have ever lived in a small village you will know!)

reply

and the bit about the flower arrangeing committee is so true, (if you have ever lived in a small village you will know!)


In a large Midwestern city, I was part of a Board meeting in which they spent at least two hours arguing about the font used on a specific fundraising letter. Luckily, I was in attendance via conference call. I would have surely not been invited back if anyone could have seen my facial expressions that day.

reply



(Spoiler)












Would a stereotypical American writer allow the nerdy British Vicar to win the day over the hunky American hero?












reply

He would if he was a man of God

reply

The film uses many stereotypes for fun and turns many on their heads. Swathes character is charming and sexy, whilst being out of place in a village like this in England but also sleazy and disgusting.

Atkinsons character seems week and afraid of showing emotion, but truly is a pationate man when shown the right path

reply