MovieChat Forums > Naina (2005) Discussion > bad bad ending *spoiler*

bad bad ending *spoiler*


Why put us through this toture if she was going to lose her eye sight anyways. Agreed that she would be traumatized for ever if she were to keep seeing dead and future tragic events but the way she loses her eye sight is really really sad. I think the concept was good but was really treated badly. This is one movie which shows how pathetically Bollywood treats potentially good supernatural concepts.The story literally comes to a stand still when Urmi goes to Gujurat. That particular sub-plot had no relevance with the main plot whatsoever. It would have been better if that gujju girl was killed by the mean guy and Urmi brings justice to the dead girl. Well! wish they could have put meat in the storyline. Too late for that to happen now I guess. LOL

reply

I haven't seen this, but I've seen the original one and it ends the same way (the Hong Kong version "Jian Gui"). I think it would have been a better ending if she killed herself and donated the eyes to someone else after death, repeating the same thing again. I still like the ending tho. Does it end with a big car exploding because of a gas tank leak? And so it hits her eyes?

"Lost" fans, come here!
www.xanga.com/fanfix_4_us_all

reply

[deleted]

This post might be deleted, but Naina's version is nearly the same, but abit longer, shes tries to save a bunch of people who go into the tube when there is a gas leak in a near by gas station? (sorry if the gas station part is wrong, i haven't seen this movie in a few months)anyhoo- there a a large explotion in the tunnel with glass and dust and such and she looses her eye again. It looks almost exactly like the Eye version- but with better imaging.

reply

For anyone that has done a bit of research into people who have regained eyesight after a long period of blindness, the ending of this movie should come as no surprise.
Also, to anyone comparing this movie with "The Eye" you might find this interesting. I recently sent "The Eye" and "Naina" to my sister to check out, and through a fluke of circumstance she watched "Naina" first. I fully expected here to say she liked "The Eye" better after watching both of them, but I was wrong. She emphatically stated that "Naina" is the better movie for elements of story and the color of the filming. I was surprised, but I think I can see it. I had the dis-advantage of having watched "The Eye" first so was always going to be biased. Anyway, there is at least one person who's opinion I respect that liked Naina over The Eye.
"...people who regained their sight later in life—after many decades of blindness— seemed to experience more difficulties in adapting to and functioning in the visual world than did those individuals who lost and regained their sight later in life."
~ Ione Fine, UCSD Psychology Department
http://ucsdnews.ucsd.edu/newsrel/soc/sightregained.htm
http://www.physorg.com/news64769651.html

reply

This whole movie was bad.

reply