MovieChat Forums > CSI: MiamiĀ (2004) Discussion > Whos better? Gil Grissom, Horatio Caine ...

Whos better? Gil Grissom, Horatio Caine or Mac Taylor


Personally, I LOVE Mac Taylor! I AM A HUGE Gary Sinise fan and i think he is totally gorgeous. Horatio would be my second pic for sure.

reply

Definitly Gil Grissom, he has this kind of Charisma and I don't know how to say but personality that really is special, mysterious, sometimes even dark. Others like Cane and Taylor are also good, but nothing beats Griss!

Rock on Grissom!

reply

Grissom, Caine or Macky...all of them have their own dark secrets. The looks in their eyes tell a different story about who they are. Gris and Macky, they are way okay in their own charming aura but personally I like Horatio Caine more. He's the best for me. Hey, emotion does play an important role in the wacky world of acting even in the real world. Well, Horatio is just a drama character who is created to be potraying a highly profesional crime scene investigator cum a policeman cum a man with humanly feelings;EMOTIONS. It's great to have the man of the law shows some respective emotions towards their clients, don't you think? And I will always love Horatio Caine for that :-) Whodunit?

reply

I sorry Gill is a bit fat for me !

Horatio Caine rocks Horatio Caine IS THE BEST !!!!!!

reply

I'm addict to..... HORATIO CAINE! 2nd would be Mac Taylor. Don't like Grissom at all but I don't hate him. Just don't like.

David and Gary are both hotties (well... they're handsome, cute, charming....)

reply

Mac is my favourite :)

reply

Johnathan Togo haha

reply

If you would have asked me a year ago it would have been hands down Horatio, but now I'm a proponent for Gil. Mac is definitely third by far. He just doesn't do the same for me.

reply

oh oh oh what?!
i heart mac

reply

Gil Grissom, all the way

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

Horatio all the way man!!!

reply

I'm big NY fan, so I must say - Mac Taylor

reply

Oh for goodness sake Horatio is so ridiculous and patronising.

Grissom for me and then Mac.

My husband and I giggle all through Horatios scenes - he is more like a caraciture.

reply

DETECTIVE MAC TAYLOR, NYPD

he's the guy in charge, ya know this.
he cares for his team, ya know this also.
he's serious most of the time, but he's not a hard-ass.
he means for people to do their jobs, totally, and not dilly-dally around while they are doing said job.
he is a man who believes in justice.
when he gets a case that hits him in a personal spot, he does everything in his power to bring the perp in.
yet, he is compassionate enough to know he's still human and makes mistakes just like everyone else.
and he knows he is only one man...not an army...and sometimes needs help...
he'll be a friend...
he'll be your boss...
he'll be there for ya when you need him the most...

"Oh, Baby, you're my drug
I was just your cigarette!"
~Miranda Lambert

reply

My picks:

Grissom
Taylor
Caine

I love Grissom and always have since I first watched Season 1. I'm a huge fan of Gary Sinise, so I decided to check out the reruns of CSI: NY and I think he does a very believable job as a CSI.

Now, Horatio on the other hand...

I like him and everything, but he seems to have this "way" about him where he tries to act tough and be intimidating, but he can't pull it off. Grissom can and Taylor can (I've seen Gary Sinise play plenty of bad guy roles, so I believe in him when it comes to intimidation), but David Caruso, personally, doesn't do it for me in the way of trying to intimidate a suspect to get information.

reply