MovieChat Forums > Brainiac: Science Abuse (2005) Discussion > Stop comparing it to Mythbusters!!!

Stop comparing it to Mythbusters!!!


It's not supposed to be anything like mythbusters!

It's lighthearted funny and pokes fun at itself.

Nobody is supposed to take it too seriously, you're supposed to watch it because they blow up caravans and make jokes and show you cool tricks you can do in the pub.

They're certainly not out to bust any myths which I see as the biggest difference for a start!!!!

For goodness' sake, just enjoy it for what it is, a fun comedy documentary which does all the things you've ever wanted to do but couldn't get away with or were to too chicken.

You lot take yourselves too seriously.

reply

i saw the episode of myth busters where they were shooting frozen and raw chicken carcasses at panes of glass to test balistics. then the part where they were testing flexibility and resonance damage of bridges. ok, fair enough, all sorts in the world.

i then watch braniac, have only missed one episode because i had things outside of my control and channel 10 seem to broadcast out of order...

but when i was doing year 11 science in high school, the instructor showed us the promise of potassium in water...brainiac in all of its infinite wisdom, showed alkali metals.

"tell me john, what is the effect we can expect?" "imagine a depth charge being let off in a bathtub" RUBIDIUM in WATER... say no more.

Brainiac is indeed the abuse of science, but if you want to take it seriously, factually prove every or at least most permutations of an experiment (and attempt to not go mad) and ultimately wander off the face of the earth, then go ahead.

i personally just cannot get enough of this and my vote has been added to the front comment. two flaming thumbs blown up!

reply

I agree, these shows are in different genres. Brainiac is a comedy show and Mythbusters is more serious. They both are good in their own categories.

reply

<<<<<<<<It's not supposed to be anything like mythbusters! >>>>>>>>>>

In that case it's an utter failure, because it's a lot like Mythbusters. In fact, they were until recently the only shows in their own genre.

reply

It is a lot like Mythbusters, but it's not supposed to be taken so seriously. So stop taking it so seriously! It's just a lighthearted, funny show.


If I wanted to hear the pitter-patter of little feet, I'd put shoes on my cat

reply