MovieChat Forums > Lonely HeartsĀ (2006) Discussion > why do people care what she looks like??

why do people care what she looks like??


The real lonely hearts killer was not nearly as hot as salma hayek but that shouldnt matter. Your not supposed to judge a movie because you think they needed to get an ugly actress to play the role. It just doesnt make sense to get somebody who looks the part when you can get somebody who can actually act the part.

reply

[deleted]

Yeah, and Morgan Freeman should play Hitler in a WW2 epic along with Ken Watanabe as FDR and Hillary Clinton as Douglas MacArthur.

Gimme a break.



Going to war without France is like going deer hunting without an accordion! - Gen. Norman Schwarzkopf

reply

uh, they also turned Martha Beck into a sexpot whore and femme fatale. that scene where she blew the cop so he wouldn't check the registration!? come on! artistic license is one thing, but that's just silly.

then again, this movie commits the even worse crime of underusing Laura Dern, so far be it for me to just nitpick at one thing.

This film was obviously the director's tribute to his grandpa (though I'm not sure how casting John Revolta can be seen as a tribute to anyone!), by portraying him as a determined cop devoting his life to catching two killers, but also with a sensitive and good-natured joking side. Martha and Ray are just part of his story.


I said "look, man, I don't take my clothes off for RIP CAGE, even if it is artistic!"

reply

I would think that most people would like john travolta to play them in a movie. I do think it was the director's tribute to his grandfather and being able to take artistic license is his right. You may not like what they turned her into, but by today's standards for movies thats what people seem to want to see.

Hate early, must kill early!
If you love Jesus copy this and make it your signature!

reply

Because the size of the woman involved in this case plays into it. While I think that Hayak's acting was excellent, i felt the could have at least padded her.

And as far as the director's grandfather, there's a picture in the dvd featurette that you can see the resemblance between Travolta and grandfather. I mean, he's the director and I am sure he would know if Travolta would or wouldn't do justice to his grandfather.

Swing away, Merrill....Merrill, swing away...

reply

[deleted]

People didn't like Salma playing Martha cuz Salma is super hot & sexy, whereas Martha was overweight & very unattractive. This wasn't like Charlize Theron making herself ugly like in "Monster," Salma was all made up & they didn't pas her out to make her look heavier or anything. Part of Martha's rage was her self-hatred, which had a lot to do with her physical appearance.

reply