MovieChat Forums > Hu die (2004) Discussion > How Could Yip Be Worthy of Flavia?

How Could Yip Be Worthy of Flavia?


Has it ever crossed your mind that Yip's joke might be true? She said that she was fooling around with another girl and got naked and thus caught the cold. How in hell would we know that she was merely joking?

Look at her selfish and deceitful nature? She pre-mediated the whole hook-up plan and cunningly allured Flavia into her trap. She took advantage of Rosa's feelings for her, lived off Rosa, and invited tons of girls to Rosa's place. Betrayal.

Just because the fact she was looking for a girl triggered the Flavia's past memory doesn't mean she's worth to keep.

I just don't understand what they see in each other. All I saw was irresponsible action and pure lust! Okay, I can see why one wanna do Flavia (Josie Ho's really hot). But Yip? Give me a break. She has no ambition, she knows nothing about loyalty or the grandeur of love (i.e. the will of putting others' needs before oneself), she can't take care of herself, she looks okay and she's a home-wrecker. So why?!!!!



I don't intend to be offensive, but I have to defend my opinions.

reply

I totally disagree. I don't think Yip was any more selfish than Flavia or the other girl. None of the characters came off as really selfless.

Yip did have ambition, she had a up and coming music career and she did up the flat for Flavia. What they saw in each other was they made the other a better person. Flavia made Yip more mature and less selfish, and Yip made Flavia happier and allowed her to be herself.

I'd die for you. I love you. I love you so much it's killing me.

reply