MovieChat Forums > Young Blades (2005) Discussion > The Female As Male Thing Never Worked

The Female As Male Thing Never Worked


While Karen Cliche's character is *supposed* to be a woman posing as a man in order to receive Musketeer training -- am I the only one who finds it really strange that the show does almost nothing to make her look male (other than putting her in a Musketeer's uniform, and occasionally having her affect a very fake-y male voice)?

It's genuinely weird when you watch the show and first realize that she's supposed to be "disguised as a man" during the proceedings. The character is so obviously female throughout the show -- an episode I saw a few days ago, the actress was clearly wearing colorless lip gloss (!!!) in a couple of scenes -- that it makes the rest of the characters seem like utter morons for never noticing that this is a woman who walks among them.

I wonder what could've been going on in the producers' heads?

reply

It's all done tongue-in-cheek, so try not to think about it too much and have fun. I think this show is aimed at 11 year olds, but it also works on the adult level, if you get all the jokes (like the old Batman tv show)


some need to go up 1 or down 1:
http://us.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=10088562

reply

141-OKG, no 11-year old on this planet is dumb enough to fall for this garbage. Adults may do so, if they are really starved for bad jokes, truly poor acting and loopholes in the plot big enough to fit a housing project!

reply

Maybe, but they DID do a good job making the Prince Louis character look like a girl trying to be a guy.............................

reply


LOL, I love Prince Louis, he is a hilarious character.

@ I didnt lose my marbles, I sold them on ebay! @

reply

Actually, the idea isn't that farfetched if you think of it in terms of the time period the characters were supposed to be living in. Historically, people in that period had no concept of what a woman would look like wearing pants instead of a dress. In other words, anyone wearing pants in public was generally assumed to be male unless proven otherwise. And effeminate-looking men weren't that unusual in that period either, especially among the upper classes. So 'Jacques'' comrades probably just figured that he was one of those types. In fact, in "The Girl from Upper Gaborski" (one of the extended scenes from the dvd version, actually), Jacqueline tells D'Artagnan that she claimed to be a nobleman when she enlisted because noblemen 'look like women.'

So, even though the audience (and D'Artagnan) know that 'Jacques LePonte' is really a woman, it really isn't that hard to believe that the other characters would assume otherwise if you put yourself in the mindset of 17th-century Parisians.

Well, that's my two cents, anyway.

reply

also if you think about it... she could easily deny it and call for a duel. in those times people were actually accountable for insulting someone.

reply

This is also the show that cast a white guy to play the writer of 3 Musketeers.

There are a number of women who passed as men throughout history but you're talking about logistics and pretend flirting to maintain such a facade.

That said, I think class trumped gender roles. Louis XV agreed to let the Countess of Brionne serve as Grand Equerry until her son was of age.

reply

I think the main problem was that it echoed "Young Riders" too much in this respect (girl dresses up like boy to join company, one of the members finds out in the first ep, etc.). Plus, they had the other Musketeers (other than the first one) find out that she was a girl too quickly. Even in the Young Riders, Buck, Cody, Ike, and Hickock didn't find about Lou bein' a girl until the fifth episode while Kid found in the first episode. In here, one Musketeer found out in the first ep, and then others found out in like the second or third ep.
Uh-oh.
Not a word you want to hear in this house.
Catch ya on the flip side.

reply